QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Aug 11 2008, 08:20 PM)

I'm not questioning whether Borielloe, Gilardino, etc. are appropriate rates at that time. I agree in the case of Boriello and Gila that they were, but that's not the point. We had Boriello, he came through our ranks, he cost nothing. Then we give half to Genoa, for basically nothing.. then we buy that half back for £6m? That is bad business, because we had him for free in the first place, we basically wasted £6m.
We had to pay something to Genoa because he produced results and his value went up. This isn't bad business. This is just a fact of life. We didn't waste anything on him I don't think.
QUOTE
Same goes for Gila, we bought him for about £17m, then sold him for about half. His performances are irrelevant, we made a bad signing which we lost money on = bad business, same for Oliveira. It doesn't work like this all the time, obviously if players are getting old their value will decrease anyway, but we're talking about throwing around £10m away on these to transfers.
I thought he would have been a great player for us. I can't agree with you again. We took a risk and that's how business works. Like Pato... that was a well worth risk that had rewards. It doesn't denote bad business. I'm not going to change my opinion here. Zambrotta has his worth and will regain his form with Milan.
QUOTE
Buying players for money, them sucking, then selling them for less in just not good business basically. Milan buy players at what we think they're worth.. if we then sell them for less, we obviously negotiated poorly in the beginning/over-paid for them. Like with Sheva we made money = good business.
We take risks and some of these risks are well worth it. Viudez and Cardacio were bought very cheaply... so I'm more in favor of that.
You have to take risks, and somethings risks don't work out.
I'm happy with Galliani and I think he should stick around. He's great and despite his mouth, he knows what he's doing. We have to take calculated risks. I was in favor of buying Oliveira at the time too... it didn't work out. THat's a fact of life.