QUOTE (Fillipo Simone @ Jun 23 2008, 04:34 PM)
No I am not. Actually I said this is just an example, that is in revent terms. Do you want more of these examples? I saw Ajax-PSV couple of years ago, I saw him play for Holland in 2006... He is just unreliable. He can make brilliant FK and assists from dead balls. That's his biggest plus. Is he a prospect? Yes. Can he perform more? Maybe. Is he a complete midfielder? NO. Most certainly not. He isn't balanced enough.
Well are Gattuso and Pirlo balanced? I don't personally see them as such, Seedorf is that type of player yes, but he needs to be replaced, and maybe Sneijder is not the exact same clone

but he would be a good replacemnt for Clarence.
And mayb e you are not basing it on just one game but from NT tournaments and a couple of Ajax games, and if we are going to compare him to Seedorf, then we can say the same thing for him since Seedorf was never as good for Holland as he was in ckub football.
And a player is allowed to have off games so Sneijder happened to have an off game when you were watching him, so what? We all know that Seedorf is also capable of those...
QUOTE (Fillipo Simone @ Jun 23 2008, 04:34 PM)
Exactly. We could have signed a couple of average guys like Rommedahl or Solari (just the first I could think of) and be relaxed for the next 2-3 years. But now we must buy backup players AND potential starters. The most frustrating thing is that we didn't use this crisis to introduce new players, like most big clubs do. But I just said Sneijder is overrated. For me he's nothing special. No fantastic add, no world class signing.
Agreed, except for the part were you say he's not a fantastic add to the squad. And that all goes down to a matter of oppinions and we are clearly not going to change each others so it's pointless to argue whether he would be a great add to the team or not.
QUOTE (Fillipo Simone @ Jun 23 2008, 04:34 PM)
And yes you are mixing up things:
You see..first you said he would be ideal for the Ambro position, then you said he would be ideal to replace Seedorf.
Okay, and what's between above average and world class?
And you never proved or convinced me why shouldn't I consider him a "above average" player. Did he anything spectacular?
I said tht he could be a replacement for both Seedorf and Ambro because he can play both positions and plat in them well, if I were thinking of a guy that would be brought in JUST for the purpose of replacing Seedorf then I would immediately think of Van Der Vaart, were as Sneijder can play in either position, since he is a versatile player.
To me when saying above average you are saying that he is
just good or decent enough. World Class is on a different scale. That is just me and how I see it. Again, just a difference of oppinion.
Again, how can I manage to convince you that he's a great player when your oppinion is otherwise? This is a forum I come on here to share
my oppinion, not to brain wash you or anyone else into agreeing with me about something. Personally I like how he plays, his style and technique just appeals to me and personally think he's a good player based on what
I myself have seen from him. That is just my oppinion though and you are free to think otherwise