QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Feb 20 2013, 01:17 AM)

It would seem so. I think it was a pointless signing in a way, almost as if they didn't need him (why did they need to replace Gomez?) and just bought him so others couldn't.
Pointless? Gomez is very injury prone, and Bayern just got rid of Petersen. So they were short of one true striker. You see, it's only recently that Gomez came back from a long injury. Also, Mario Madzukic can play as a winger, which gives them even more tactical edge.
QUOTE (acid911 @ Feb 20 2013, 08:36 AM)

True, Neuer is just a good keeper, surely does not seem like he has that extra special something that separates players like him from the greats.

Buffon, Casillas, Kahn and friends were in a different league altogether. Wonder when we'll see another great goalkeeper, most in the last few years have been just okay.
They replaced Gomez because some doofus in the higher management of Bayern thought that he was not a good player. Basically, they needed someone to put the blame of the final loss, and it was Gomez and Robben who took the fall.

And well that Boateng brother too, but he wasn't anywhere near quality, anyway.
You're listing the best keepers, not just now but for the last 2 decades. Sure, Neuer isn't on eyesight and he makes those goofs every now and then but he still hasn't peaked. We'll see, he's 26, still time to get better.
As for the blame...well, I wouldn't say it's undeserved when it comes to Robben. Also, I really don't see how he'd fit in Heynckens system anyway. He's a good sub, and he can bring the extra element in the game. But as a starter he tends to make always the same runs, the same tricks and dribbles and once people noticed this repetition, he gets nervous and disappears.
Boateng didn't take the blame, he actually started this season as a starter, but his poor performances ensured him the bench.
As I said, Gomez was injured. I didn't seem to pick up any blame towards him for the lost final?