Dst is not fair on his judgement on kaladze , even if he plays good he wont praise him. Same goes out for Porty. But if he plays a bad game they're like selling him asap

Well, Kaladze makes us look bad. He is more Inter material if you ask me.

And yet, it's his 8th year as a Rossoneri

He's useful as a sub player, and as such should stay in Milan, but not as a starter.

That might be true but this was definately not his only mistake, he's done countless ones in the past.

For me he is a starter. For Milan he's a starter. So ...

How do you mean he is a starter? After this match, Carletto will put Bonera or even Å imić in charge with Nesta. Till Paolo is fit. This season, Paolo and Sandro are starters, next season it will be a new CB and Sandro, so in every combination Kala is bench material .

He's certainly no starter, he ONLY starts when somebody is injured.

I wouldn't expect Maldini to be replaced though, I can see it now. "We've already got two great centre backs in Bonera and Kaladze, we don't need anyone else."

And the worst thing is that you are almost certainly right. Let's think about it - for next season Silvio still dreams Ronaldinho, so that's one transfer. Sergio and Cafu are gonna stop, so we need a extra LB or RB (which could also be just one person - guess who? ) so that's transfer number two (or even two and three). Then Dida is gonna be covered cause every normal person can see how he is deteriorating, so that's the third transfer. If Gila leaves, we have to find a replacement, that's number four.

Anyone thinks Milan will make 5 transfers in one campaign?? Hmh,...

Maybe if:
Winter: new GK and Gila swap/transfer
Summer 2008: the LB/RB and Ronaldinho

Kakha over the span of his career with Milan has been an integral part in helping the team to win several titles. He is not an average player .. He is one with experience and knows what the coach wants of him.

Still with that said, he is no were near Nesta or Maldini's quality .. Who is ?! He provides us with options on the flanks and in defense ( though he is used as a cb mostly nowadays..). And sure his performance in this match was below average and was bad at clearing that ball, but in the end you have to ask your question; whom in our team played well ?

It is the start of the season, and Milan always takes time to get in gear !! Maybe you have one or two players in tip top form, but the team collectively aren't at 100%. And Kakha falls right in there with the team that he has given a lot throughout his career here.

Now if you want to criticize him .. Go ahead, but take into account that he will be crucial again for us .. As he has been for us over the years.

Ahem... maybe you've seen some good games from him but I have not!


Oh, this is nasty! If our next campaign is ruined again in the wait for Ronaldinho I'm going to Milan to kick some Ash... seriously!

^^

I don't need to go to Milan to kick some Ash.
I just head to the V2 thread.

Yes you did , you just dont want to admit it.

Oh, OK...