Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: WC 2018/2022
AC Milan - Milanfan.com > General Football > Football Discussion
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
Milan Are Brilliant
Just looking at it from a different angle, wouldn't qualification have to be bought forward as well, thus cluttering up the season even before? I think it would be unfair to make fans wait until the last minute to see if their team has got through. It's a farce.

On top of this FIFA want to make it a global sport? Well, good luck, the Americans aren't going to watch this over their NFL playoffs, even the ones that watch the game. Aren't the Winter Olympics at this time too? again bringing viewing figures down.
kurtsimonw
I think you have it horribly wrong mate.

Villa's games from last seasons winter period onwards:

December: 7
January: 7
February: 6
March: 6
April: 6
May: 2 (Then the FA Cup Final week the following week).

Also take into consideration we didn't play in Europe, which would add 2 or 3 games a month from Feb onwards, so you're looking at 9/10 games a month.

So please tell me where the World Cup fits in and where the games the World Cup would cancel would be re-scheduled? You've got the break before the World Cup for the squads to meet up, the actual World Cup, then the rest after the World Cup. What's that, a total of around 7 weeks? 7 weeks from January/February for teams in Europe is going to be about 17/18 games. 17/18 games added on to Mid-May is going to take 10/12 weeks no? Unless you actually expect player to play half a season, a World Cup and then have to play twice a week for the remainder of season? Even then it'll take 8 weeks and take it to the end of July! But realistically speaking, you're looking at the season ending at about the time the next season should be starting. Then players need a 6 week break, so the following season would start about October.

You're logic is using time, rather than games. Judging by your comments the way you're seeing it is "You basically swap January and June around", but then you're not taking into consideration break before the World Cup, the fact that you're then expecting teams to play twice a week, every week, after playing none-stop for a year, then it'd mean no break following the World Cup.
dst
Of course I take it into consideration but let's talk in dates as you prefer. You say the WC needs about 7 weeks which I think is right. Well the EPL season ends at the beginning of May every season (bar the 08-09 one when it ended at the end of May). Add to that those 7 weeks and that's the beginning of July... can you please show me where the problem is? If it's done in the EPL then it can be done everywhere. I'm sure the players will have no problem with it. Actually, if I was a player I'd prefer the smoother in schedule WC cutting a hard season in half. I see a bigger issue with players having a problem with the hiatus in fact (you seem to forget that only a limited number of players from each league participate in the WC). It only remains to be seen. If the move to January becomes official we'll surely hear from the players.

QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Jan 15 2011, 06:28 PM) *
On top of this FIFA want to make it a global sport? Well, good luck, the Americans aren't going to watch this over their NFL playoffs, even the ones that watch the game. Aren't the Winter Olympics at this time too? again bringing viewing figures down.

now that's a good point.
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (dst @ Jan 15 2011, 05:20 PM) *
Of course I take it into consideration but let's talk in dates as you prefer. You say the WC needs about 7 weeks which I think is right. Well the EPL season ends at the beginning of May every season (bar the 08-09 one when it ended at the end of May). Add to that those 7 weeks and that's the beginning of July... can you please show me where the problem is? If it's done in the EPL then it can be done everywhere.

Again, you're talking in time and not games.

7 weeks over Dec/Jan/Feb is around 18-20 games in England. There is absoloutely no way you can expect players to play a 10 month season (August to May) and then have to play every weekend and every week day you're expecting. They'll pretty much be playing twice a week, every week, for an entire year. It's not realistic at all. 6 games a month is still playing once every 5 days on average, but even that would take 3 months after the season to complete, which would mean the season finishes in August (3 months after May is August).

Your reasoning seems to be "if they can play that many games in Jan, they can do it in June". There's 2 things wrong with that, 1) as I've already said, after playing an entire year, it'd be unrealistic for them to do the winter period in June, teams literally play about 4 games in 7 days. 2) there's a reason that the EPL doesn't play football competitively in June/July and the start of August (no doubt the same reason most leagues start later than ours and also the reason the WC is being moved in the first place) and that's the heat. A World Cup isn't as bad because most teams play about 4/5 games max, but you want teams to play like 18 games in this weather over a space of last than 2 months? We'll see how happy the players are then.

W're clearly not going to agree though, I think it's not fair on the players and not healthy, you disagree. Fair enough. I'd still rather us pull out.
servbot
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jan 15 2011, 10:01 AM) *
It's really not as simple as just putting the World Cup in January either, do you really think all the national teams will want no time together for a few weeks before hand? It could possibly take up 2 months of the season, not just 1. Which would mean the season would finish closer to August - when the next season is meant to start.


Wouldn't the best solution be to have a shorter pre-season then? Will teams really need 6 weeks of pre-season if they've been playing all year already? Finish mid-July, take 4 weeks off to get some rest, practice for 2, and start next season at end August/early September. That would only throw it off schedule a little bit.


QUOTE ("MilanAreBrilliant")
Well, good luck, the Americans aren't going to watch this over their NFL playoffs, even the ones that watch the game.


This is true, but because of the time zone difference, and that NFL playoffs are only on Saturday and Sunday, I think most games would be unaffected by the NFL. To be honest, from a strictly U.S. sports fan point-of-view, it would be awesome to have the World Cup in February, just after the NFL ends, because that's kind of the dead month of sports here.
Milan Are Brilliant
Though the WC final is always on a Sunday (I think, at least in recent years) and the big games are often at the weekends, this would clash with the NFL. Unless people don't sleep for 24 hours I don't know how it won't affect viewing figures. Obviously, I don't know the time differences for localised areas in America and Qatar.
Brian Birkin
I agree that players maybe finding a better run of form in January, many players are tired as it is now.

But I think it is important to remember that it is long time to go at this moment, and I think there should be caution with saying a lot now. I am confident that if there is World Cup in January there will be a way thought out for it.
servbot
QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Jan 15 2011, 03:16 PM) *
Though the WC final is always on a Sunday (I think, at least in recent years) and the big games are often at the weekends, this would clash with the NFL. Unless people don't sleep for 24 hours I don't know how it won't affect viewing figures. Obviously, I don't know the time differences for localised areas in America and Qatar.


An 8 PM game in Doha would be at 12 noon in New York, 11 AM in Chicago, and 9 AM on the West Coast. (I had to look it up). That would make it 5 PM in Europe, I believe.

So it would coincide with a Sunday NFL playoff game (1 PM NY time start) besides the Super Bowl, which is played in the evening.
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (servbot @ Jan 16 2011, 07:37 AM) *
That would make it 5 PM in Europe, I believe.

Only GMT European countries. I think most of Europe is +1/+2 though, so it'd be 6/7. But yeah, you're right, you'd likely miss the early playoff games at the weekend if you wanted to watch the WC.
servbot
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jan 16 2011, 01:42 AM) *
Only GMT European countries. I think most of Europe is +1/+2 though, so it'd be 6/7. But yeah, you're right, you'd likely miss the early playoff games at the weekend if you wanted to watch the WC.


Is GMT like Daylight Savings Time here, where in spring the clocks go forward an hour, then back an hour in fall? I know it changes a little because I remember a couple Milan games last spring starting an hour different, so either Italy switched or we switched first and the other caught up a couple of weeks later.

Or, I'm probably a moron...on real thought GMT is probably a timezone (G for Greenwich?)

Final edit...I figured it all out, looks like there's a two-week difference in the standard/daylight savings schedule.
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (servbot @ Jan 16 2011, 07:48 AM) *
Is GMT like Daylight Savings Time here, where in spring the clocks go forward an hour, then back an hour in fall? I know it changes a little because I remember a couple Milan games last spring starting an hour different, so either Italy switched or we switched first and the other caught up a couple of weeks later.

Or, I'm probably a moron...on real thought GMT is probably a timezone (G for Greenwich?)

Final edit...I figured it all out, looks like there's a two-week difference in the standard/daylight savings schedule.

GMT is a timezone yeah. I don't know if it's just because I'm English, but I think GMT is generally seen as 0? Then you have CET which is GMT +1 and so on.
servbot
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jan 16 2011, 01:54 AM) *
GMT is a timezone yeah. I don't know if it's just because I'm English, but I think GMT is generally seen as 0? Then you have CET which is GMT +1 and so on.


For some reason when I read "GMT countries" my brain farted. Yeah I've seen the +1, +2, etc before, and yes GMT is seen as 0, but it's not common to see here as everything that isn't local-only is compared to New York time (another case of Ameri-centrism, perhaps?), which is listed as EST (E=Eastern).

Although maybe the winter WC won't happen? ESPN SoccerNet:

QUOTE
Far from impressed with Blatter's repeated claims that the tournament could be held at a different time, AFC chief Mohamed bin Hammam, who led the successful Qatar bid, has hit back by saying he firmly expected the World Cup to take place in the summer despite the "health risks" raised by a FIFA evaluation.

"We submitted a bid suggesting we are going to be ready in June and July. And we said we are going to face all the challenges and we are going to meet all the requirements. Our focus is June, July. It is never our interest to change one week beyond June and July," bin Hamman told Sky News.

Furthermore, in response to UEFA president Michel Platini's proposal that Qatar may be asked to "share" the World Cup so that it is played across the whole of the Gulf, bin Hammam retorted: "Qatar can stand alone and organise the competition by itself."

Blatter continued to draw further criticism with a startling admission during an interview with CNN on Thursday, when he admitted that FIFA committee members "vote more with their heart than they vote with their head."
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (servbot @ Jan 16 2011, 08:06 AM) *
For some reason when I read "GMT countries" my brain farted. Yeah I've seen the +1, +2, etc before, and yes GMT is seen as 0, but it's not common to see here as everything that isn't local-only is compared to New York time (another case of Ameri-centrism, perhaps?), which is listed as EST (E=Eastern).

I don't think it's Ameri-centrism (if that's even a word/expression!?), just a way to distinguish times between the different timezones that may view the same programme. A little OT, but what's the 4th timezone called? I hear on the NFL that they say Eastern, Pacific and Mid-West alot, what about the other? And is Chicago Mid-West, or is Denver?

Awesome news about the WC though, Mo's making a good impression on me already!
servbot
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jan 16 2011, 02:17 AM) *
I don't think it's Ameri-centrism (if that's even a word/expression!?), just a way to distinguish times between the different timezones that may view the same programme. A little OT, but what's the 4th timezone called? I hear on the NFL that they say Eastern, Pacific and Mid-West alot, what about the other? And is Chicago Mid-West, or is Denver?

Awesome news about the WC though, Mo's making a good impression on me already!


Can I get credit for making it up then? smile.gif I'm sure I've heard the term somewhere though.

The one you're missing is called Mountain, which would be only Denver I think as far as big cities go. Chicago time is called Central here, but calling it mid-west would be appropriate too since that's what the area is called.
Rossoneri7
For those interested in the 2022 WC bid and how things are shaping up ... Qatar's CTC (Centeral Tendering Committee) will be in collaboration with the region's qualified companies to bid for projects in the pipe-line.

The job descriptions are valued at over USD $50 billion; the total scope of work is @ USD $160 billion. The initial $50 billion is the value of stadiums and relevant hotels/resorts, while the remaining USD 110 billion is for infrastructural works to build Qatar.

Amongst the names of companies to be invited are the GCC's biggest contractors such as; Bin Laden Group, Kharafi National, Combined Group, and Ahmadia.


I wish I could indulge in the bashing of Qatar ... But considering the above, the 2022 WC could very well be one to remember, considering by 2022 Qatar will be the most advanced nation on earth in terms of its infrastructure.


For those who do not understand what infrastructure is .... It simply means the foundations of a country ie; airports, roads, bridges, underground wiring, telecommunications, shipping ports, and all relevant pieces that make up a country.
Locke Lamora
QUOTE (Rossoneri7 @ Jan 16 2011, 11:19 AM) *
For those interested in the 2022 WC bid and how things are shaping up ... Qatar's CTC (Centeral Tendering Committee) will be in collaboration with the region's qualified companies to bid for projects in the pipe-line.

The job descriptions are valued at over USD $50 billion; the total scope of work is @ USD $160 billion. The initial $50 billion is the value of stadiums and relevant hotels/resorts, while the remaining USD 110 billion is for infrastructural works to build Qatar.

Amongst the names of companies to be invited are the GCC's biggest contractors such as; Bin Laden Group, Kharafi National, Combined Group, and Ahmadia.


I wish I could indulge in the bashing of Qatar ... But considering the above, the 2022 WC could very well be one to remember, considering by 2022 Qatar will be the most advanced nation on earth in terms of its infrastructure.


For those who do not understand what infrastructure is .... It simply means the foundations of a country ie; airports, roads, bridges, underground wiring, telecommunications, shipping ports, and all relevant pieces that make up a country.




Ok, who didn't at least smirk at that one?
kurtsimonw
biggrin.gif

I think them getting it (combined with Russia) stinks of £££ and I am 100% opposed to the January idea, but I don't really doubt the country in terms of getting ready.

My main concern is the support, it'd be terrible to set empty stadiums for WC games, let's hope it drastically improves upon the Asian Cup figures.
Rossoneri7
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jan 16 2011, 05:34 PM) *
biggrin.gif

I think them getting it (combined with Russia) stinks of £££ and I am 100% opposed to the January idea, but I don't really doubt the country in terms of getting ready.

My main concern is the support, it'd be terrible to set empty stadiums for WC games, let's hope it drastically improves upon the Asian Cup figures.


Ofcourse it does ... Its the mother of all jackpots ... I would even bet you that the figures that were sent to the UEFA headquarters was mindboggling, and I bet you that most of it didn't come from Qatar wink.gif

I hate it ... I find it uncouth, but you are talking about a nation that cashed in on its Natural Gas fields for the next ten years. Wallstreet and Canary wharf were rubbing their hands when the votes were announced ... Do you know what will bail out Greece, Spain, Italy ? Let alone kick-start the whole global economy? Qatar ? ... Yes that tiny ****-hole !

Obsequestrianista
QUOTE (Locke Lamora @ Jan 16 2011, 10:39 AM) *
Ok, who didn't at least smirk at that one?


Well once they've got over the property crash it should be plane sailing from there on in.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2026 Invision Power Services, Inc.