Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: WC 2018/2022
AC Milan - Milanfan.com > General Football > Football Discussion
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
Ry4n
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Dec 15 2010, 04:52 PM) *
I'm actually surprised you agree with me on this! biggrin.gif

I'm at the point now where I really don't care about International football. Do I want England to win games? Sure, every one of them. Do I care if we don't even qualify? Not really.

biggrin.gif

I did watch a program on the bbc news they were talking about the world cup bids and how each country bidding would fair in it , with getting the votes and they came to conclusion the england bidding team did'nt really work the room well enough to get the votes or they were secured nor backed completely by the voting members , this was a week before the votes so i wrote england off from there but they thought America did a little better when trying to gain the votes and could have sealed it.
dst
QUOTE (milanbuf88 @ Dec 15 2010, 05:13 AM) *
What people from the Middle East don't seem to understand is that FIFA made a farce of the entire voting process with the 2022 selection. Countries spent millions of dollars assembling a presentation of a bid to demonstrate the way in which the country can handle the hosting of an event of such magnitude and do it in a sustainable, efficient manner. The USA bid was exactly what FIFA said it wanted. Then they turned around and gave the WC to the country least able to present it in that way. If they were just going to randomly select the host on, best case, a whim or, worst case, a bribe why have a bidding process at all? Why have any semblance of objectivity? Just let FIFA request that their favorite country or richest friends host it since that is clearly what they did anyway.

How do you know the USA bid was exactly what FIFA wanted? And how do you know the Qatar bid was not? None of us have seen the files...

I don't like FIFA and I don't like Blatter. They are corrupt. They are harming football. I would not be surprised a bit if it was revealed that they actually were bribed - I too believe they were. What I cannot understand is why it is presented as if the US and England bids were that much better than the Russia and Qatar ones. I just don't get it. It's one thing to say that they won because they bribed FIFA and another to say that Qatar can't hold an equally good tournament as the other two.

As I said, none of us have seen the files and until someone who has comes out and thoroughly tells us what differentiates them I'm only going to believe FIFA were bribed not that the any presentation was superior.

QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Dec 15 2010, 02:04 PM) *
Like you say, FIFA's evaluating commitee even said that England and the USA had the best cases in terms of their bid. Yet in the first round of voting, both did terrible. This makes no logical sense.

Would you mind finding that for me?
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (dst @ Dec 16 2010, 01:36 PM) *
How do you know the USA bid was exactly what FIFA wanted? And how do you know the Qatar bid was not? None of us have seen the files...

I don't like FIFA and I don't like Blatter. They are corrupt. They are harming football. I would not be surprised a bit if it was revealed that they actually were bribed - I too believe they were. What I cannot understand is why it is presented as if the US and England bids were that much better than the Russia and Qatar ones. I just don't get it. It's one thing to say that they won because they bribed FIFA and another to say that Qatar can't hold an equally good tournament as the other two.

I'm not even getting into it, it's been done to death. If you're going to host in Qatar, then London could easily host a World Cup on it's own, it has more bigger stadiums! (This is a joke, by the way, it's impossible for a City to host a World Cup).

QUOTE (dst @ Dec 16 2010, 01:36 PM) *
Would you mind finding that for me?


The official FIFA evaluation PDF files are all over the net, it's a simple google search.
dst
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Dec 17 2010, 05:25 AM) *
I'm not even getting into it, it's been done to death. If you're going to host in Qatar, then London could easily host a World Cup on it's own, it has more bigger stadiums! (This is a joke, by the way, it's impossible for a City to host a World Cup).

Of course London has more bigger stadiums... but they're doing this now so that the country which has its bid selected (one way or another) will be ready when the time comes. Not now. 11 years in the future!

Why wouldn't London be able to host a WC on its own? I imagine London might had had (or could have had) all four of Arsenal, Chelsea, Tottenham and West Ham playing at the same day... and a World Cup does not require more than that.

I don't understand why you think hosting a WC is so unbelievably difficult. I will again mention the Olympics... which are bigger (in everything) and cost almost 10 times as much.

QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Dec 17 2010, 05:25 AM) *
The official FIFA evaluation PDF files are all over the net, it's a simple google search.

OK then I will! And I'll come back to ya! devil.gif
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (dst @ Dec 17 2010, 01:38 PM) *
I don't understand why you think hosting a WC is so unbelievably difficult. I will again mention the Olympics... which are bigger (in everything) and cost almost 10 times as much.

England's main negative was the lack of facilities to accomodate the stupid amounts of people that would come into the country for the WC (something the Olympics don't have, people don't really travel for it, unlike the WC). A single CIty has no chance at all, not even close, even the likes of New York who have constant tourism on a large scale.

QUOTE (dst @ Dec 17 2010, 01:38 PM) *
Why wouldn't London be able to host a WC on its own? I imagine London might had had (or could have had) all four of Arsenal, Chelsea, Tottenham and West Ham playing at the same day... and a World Cup does not require more than that.

Premier League fixtures are done to make sure that doesn't happen, but I'll go along with it. Do these teams have millions of people coming in from over the World to accomodate? No, probably a few hundred, the rest already live in London.

You seem to only look at the on the field stuff, in which case a single stadium could host a World Cup, but that's not how it works.
dst
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Dec 17 2010, 03:59 PM) *
England's main negative was the lack of facilities to accomodate the stupid amounts of people that would come into the country for the WC (something the Olympics don't have, people don't really travel for it, unlike the WC). A single CIty has no chance at all, not even close, even the likes of New York who have constant tourism on a large scale.

People don't travel for the Olympics? I don't know where you got this from but I could not stand living in Athens during the Olympics, it was just too crowded. And not just near the facilities (which are scattered everywhere in the city unlike a couple of football stadia), everywhere!

QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Dec 17 2010, 03:59 PM) *
Premier League fixtures are done to make sure that doesn't happen, but I'll go along with it. Do these teams have millions of people coming in from over the World to accomodate? No, probably a few hundred, the rest already live in London.

You seem to only look at the on the field stuff, in which case a single stadium could host a World Cup, but that's not how it works.

Almost all of those people would travel to England via London. And most of them would stay in London anyway. Forget it, I know I'm pushing it, it's certainly not as simple as I'm suggesting but I'm equally certain it's not as difficult as you suggest either.
Obsequestrianista
Well,

QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Dec 15 2010, 12:40 PM) *
There's no point dissecting that post, it was written in a WordPress blog by someone with as much opinion as anyone on here.


You're right that it's only worth the same as an opinion on here.

Whether because of that

QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Dec 15 2010, 12:40 PM) *
it doesn't mean anything.


I'm not sure. Some of the more longstanding forumistas might disagree.

QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Dec 15 2010, 12:40 PM) *
Bar the Platini quote within the bold section nothing else is factual, I'm not even 100% sure if that's sourced correctly.


Did you see the BBC story it was linked to that carried the story?

QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Dec 15 2010, 12:40 PM) *
The fact that the next post is "Lady Gaga is controlled by the Illuminati" says it all.


Does it? Even if you know it was a spoof and written by a completely different author?

:~

It's not so much that...

QUOTE
Look at the countries that were picked as well, Qatar and Russia. It does tie in with the "We don't want to give the WC to a country who will speak up against us", because those 2 certainly won't. What;s the betting on China 2026?


...those countries won't be critical of FIFA. They will, just as South Africa or Germany were. But at least the criticism will be reasonably fair and accountable.

Can we not see a bit of Humbug at work when the Daily Mail, not known as being a great advocate of Man Love, uses it to slap Sepp about?

Part of the bid process is being able to demonstrate that you have public support behind the idea that their country will be transformed for a few years, and then completely overrun for a month. The easiest way to detect the pulse of a nation is through its media.

And unfortunately for us, ours was unremittingly negative and cynical about FIFA and their World Cup. Long before panorama, and about things completely aside from allegations of fraud.
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (Obsequestrianista @ Dec 17 2010, 04:15 PM) *
You're right that it's only worth the same as an opinion on here. Whether because of that. I'm not sure. Some of the more longstanding forumistas might disagree.

Right, in my mind if you source something that claims 'The Reason England Didn’t Get the World Cup?' it really should be from a reliable source, like, for example the press. A WordPress blog takes what, 3 minutes to set-up (if that), a MySQL database with a PHP enabled server? You can even host it through WordPress if that were too complex as seems the case here.

It's then themed in a relatively default manner (no other customisation), and someone has made a banner in something that closely resembles WordArt.

QUOTE
Did you see the BBC story it was linked to that carried the story?

As I stated in my original post...
QUOTE
Bar the Platini quote within the bold section nothing else is factual, I'm not even 100% sure if that's sourced correctly.

So you did source the original quote somewhat correctly but the rest of that statement still seems to be true.
QUOTE
Even if you know it was a spoof and written by a completely different author?

It still came under the same blog and was the next blog on from it. It was a quick reason as to discount the source. Though I could say things like, there are no comments, there's no way to integrate it with social networks, there's no real reason as to why this would be an article of reliable source. The blog has been going since July 2010 so is hardly that well-known, or experienced within writing articles on footballing matters. Perhaps it was just a way to create links to your website in the hope of boosting a few of your unique hits.
-------------------------------------
If you had come on here and posted it as an opinion it would have been completely different. Though for someone to reference it as a source is a bit ludicrous, it would basically mean every poster on here could go and make a WordPress blog, write a blog and then use it as a source. So if I go and write a transfer rumour I could then use that as a source for the basis of my argument, which really isn't the idea of sourcing. Obviously there are different levels of blogs, in terms of popularity etc so that could be extended somewhat but in this case I don't see how that can be.
Obsequestrianista
QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Dec 17 2010, 05:35 PM) *
Right, in my mind if you source something that claims 'The Reason England Didn’t Get the World Cup?' it really should be from a reliable source, like, for example the press. A WordPress blog takes what, 3 minutes to set-up (if that), a MySQL database with a PHP enabled server? You can even host it through WordPress if that were too complex as seems the case here.


Yes wordpress blogs are very easy to set up. But I'm not sure that makes the opinion expressed within that posting less relevant. Nor does the same blog containing other random stuff about bent lamposts, sheep with blue wool, or whatever. And from different authors.

How is the press a comparitively reliable source? A blog is no more and no less a reliable source than a newspaper editorial.
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (Obsequestrianista @ Dec 17 2010, 05:49 PM) *
Yes wordpress blogs are very easy to set up. But I'm not sure that makes the opinion expressed within that posting less relevant. Nor does the same blog containing other random stuff about bent lamposts, sheep with blue wool, or whatever. And from different authors.

How is the press a comparitively reliable source? A blog is no more and no less a reliable source than a newspaper editorial.

It sort of does, because it's quicker and easier to setup a WordPress blog than it is going out and getting an article into a newspaper per se. The other stuff like that, takes down the reliability factor when you are trying to blog about serious stuff, and want the audience to take you seriously. It's like trying to mix Perez Hilton's Blog with the White House Blog, it doesn't really work.

To write in a newspaper, you are trained and qualified (usually) for a start. You have the risk of lawsuits such as slander, losing your job etc. You write to a far greater audience (at least in this case), you are usually a person of experience in the particular field you are writing about or you are writing it from a primary perspective as oppose to secondary as is the case here.

What I'm trying to get at is anyone with access to the web can set-up and write a blog, I doubt anyone can walk into a newspaper, or other forms of editorial and work for them. That's why there's difference in the sources and why a blog is (usually) far less reliable than a newspaper editorial.
Brian Birkin
I agree it is easy to set up blog, but I figure some journalists write what they want, sometimes even with the risk of a lawsuit. I can vouch for how much **** I have seen from some media regarding Zlatan. One cannot depend on them being trained or qualified, they can still **** with people in some ways if they wish to.

The difference between some bloggers and some journalists is that the journalist has a salary.
kurtsimonw
Has anybody seen any mention on how they're going to have a winter World Cup? It doesn't really seem possible to me. In England the winter period is the busiest and clubs play about 8 or 9 games in the space of a month, how're we going to fit them in elswhere? I reas somewhere that we'll have to finish our season alot later, but then thus will have a knock-on effect of the next season because players will still need a break. So the following season will start later. While it doesn't seem a problem at first, we'll be finishing our season at the end of June, so players now don't get a break for the Euros, it's just not realistic.

I hope we either drop out or don't qualify. With any luck, Harry Redknapp will be our manager then!
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jan 7 2011, 03:08 AM) *
Has anybody seen any mention on how they're going to have a winter World Cup? It doesn't really seem possible to me. In England the winter period is the busiest and clubs play about 8 or 9 games in the space of a month, how're we going to fit them in elswhere? I reas somewhere that we'll have to finish our season alot later, but then thus will have a knock-on effect of the next season because players will still need a break. So the following season will start later. While it doesn't seem a problem at first, we'll be finishing our season at the end of June, so players now don't get a break for the Euros, it's just not realistic.

I hope we either drop out or don't qualify. With any luck, Harry Redknapp will be our manager then!

We should make sure we don't qualify really, we're not going to win it in Qatar, we're not likely to win it anywhere, but Qatar we have absolutely no chance. Going there is just a useless waste of time, especially when it hampers the domestic league. Send our Championship players they're probably more hungry than the guys we have in our team anyway. Though a lot of our league is made up of foreigners so it wouldn't really make much difference. The only thing I think (as strange as it sounds) is to have a cut down league one season, literally just 1 game between teams not home and away otherwise this is going to have a knock on effect for as long as I can see, unless the FA re-arranges the English League season or drops all cup games (apart from Europe) and needless friendly internationals.
kurtsimonw
It would be nice if the FA pulled out of it, I think they'd be surprisedat the amount of respect they would gain within the country. Judging by what I read on forums, I'm one of the few that has no preference in the club vs country arguement, but the Villa forum I used had something like 95% club over country, so I think the majority wouldn't care if we pulled out.

The idea that "most countries have an international break so it won't matter" is stupid. I think - given comments made by Blatter, Platini et al - it's a little much to expect players to play August-November, play a World Cup, then play January-June. 10 months none-stop with a few weeks until the next season? Get out.
Milan Are Brilliant
I wouldn't care, it's obviously not footballing reasons why this is being held in Qatar. We're useless at the moment so that's probably why, if we had a team like Spain we would probably be more for our country again! Though, when idiots like Rooney play so poorly, don't even try and moan at the fans (the people who gave the bin-dipper his flashy job) it's not hard to see why more prefer their clubs over here.

Disclaimer: Before people go off on one I will remind you that England bid for 2018, not 2022 this has nothing to do with England losing the WC, jealousy or because Kurt & I think it's the 'bestest' league in the world.
kurtsimonw
Yeah I certainly have less problem with the Russia bid, though if what's being rumoued as to what Blatter said is true, I wouldn't be against us pulling out of that one either out of principle. Though as it won't affect the EPL season I don't really care if we don't.
Milan Are Brilliant
Oh, Kurt.

You will like this...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/9297416.stm
kurtsimonw
"we can change anything within the bid".

So what's the point of a country bidding them if FIFA just change what they want anyway? Stupid.
Brian Birkin
I do not want to say too much because I do not want to seem like a bad loser.
It has been declared since before that FIFA wants new countries to be hosts, it may be they follow this line.
Locke Lamora
"Meanwhile, Blatter also revealed in December that several nations in the Middle East were interested in hosting games during the 2022 World Cup and that he had met with officials in Oman, Bahrain and Kuwait during a tour of the region."

... say what? So we've got a host nation which won't actually host all the games? We're looking at a '2022 World Cup - Quatar (feat. Oman, Bahrain & Kuwait' or something.

Still... Blatter is 74. Swiss life expectancy is 79. Just sayin'.
kurtsimonw
It gets better every day doesn't it.
Jack Bauer
QUOTE (Locke Lamora @ Jan 7 2011, 09:34 PM) *
Still... Blatter is 74. Swiss life expectancy is 79. Just sayin'.

Not that his successor would (prabably) be any better. The whole organization is rotten.
Locke Lamora
QUOTE (Jack Bauer @ Jan 7 2011, 07:27 PM) *
Not that his successor would (prabably) be any better. The whole organization is rotten.


Well he can hardly be worse, can he? And anyway, some variation would be nice... I'd rather have a different idiot in charge every now and then than to have the same old derp droning on for decades.
dst
QUOTE (Locke Lamora @ Jan 7 2011, 07:34 PM) *
Still... Blatter is 74. Swiss life expectancy is 79. Just sayin'.

So you're saying let's kill him he's gonna die soon anyway?

QUOTE (Jack Bauer @ Jan 7 2011, 08:27 PM) *
Not that his successor would (prabably) be any better. The whole organization is rotten.

+1

QUOTE (Locke Lamora @ Jan 7 2011, 08:35 PM) *
Well he can hardly be worse, can he? And anyway, some variation would be nice... I'd rather have a different idiot in charge every now and then than to have the same old derp droning on for decades.

laugh.gif
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (dst @ Jan 7 2011, 08:49 PM) *
So you're saying let's kill him he's gonna die soon anyway?

biggrin.gif
Locke Lamora
QUOTE (dst @ Jan 7 2011, 09:49 PM) *
So you're saying let's kill him he's gonna die soon anyway?


Nah, I'm saying that with some luck we'll be rid of him within a couple of years... not that I'd ever want such a thing (it's only a game, after all), I'm just saying it's possible.
kurtsimonw
Mohammed Bin Hammam is apparently the most likely man to take over Blatter at FIFA and as early as May.

I know nothing about the guy, but anybody less racist and corrupt as Blatter is good in my books. Hell, I'd have taken Hitler.

Anyways, I stated the lack of support as a concern for the World Cup as I don't think people will go. It's all well and good people turning up for Brazil games and whatever, but unless you're getting big crowds for the 'bad' games, then it's not going to be a success.

Average attendance for the Asian Cup so far, 13k. When you consider that the host nation Qatar got 37k for their opening game (nearly 15k less than the capacity) and then only got 30k for the 2nd game (they lost the first game so a drop in interest), it's pretty worrying about the rest of the attendance figures. Nearly half of the fans that've been to games so far went to the 2 Qatar games, then there's only been 80k fans for the other 11 games - just over 7k a game. To put it into perspective, that's less than the average attendance of League 2 (4th division) clubs Bradford and Oxford and a lower average attendance than what League 1 (3rd division) gets.
Milan Are Brilliant
Exactly what I was saying a few months ago about SA and how they didn't come close to selling out unless it was a massive club, or England tongue.gif.

I thought getting the WC to Qatar was a main reason in keeping Blatter in charge. That was the rumour I was hearing.

Attendances like that are poor, really poor doesn't really show the pure 'love of the game' as I've heard. Just shows they want to see Brazil, Spain, Argentina etc. That's not really what the WC is solely about.
kurtsimonw
I don't expect them to sell out 'bad' games, far from it. But they're getting like 3k for some games which is ridiculous.
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jan 14 2011, 05:04 PM) *
I don't expect them to sell out 'bad' games, far from it. But they're getting like 3k for some games which is ridiculous.

It would have probably been the same in SA... if they weren't giving the tickets away. 80% of the fans just went to blow the Vuvuzuela's the whole game.

Plus South Africa many people still like to visit as a tourist attraction, even though it's incredibly dangerous in parts. I've never really heard of people going on holiday to Qatar.
kurtsimonw
Plus if it's moved to January then people will find it difficult to travel there, prices in the winter are ridiculous.
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jan 14 2011, 05:27 PM) *
Plus if it's moved to January then people will find it difficult to travel there, prices in the winter are ridiculous.

Good point, well at least here and most of Europe. Obviously I can't speak for the whole of the world in that.

I'm still bemused by the decision, completely. Moving it to January just seems to make it an even worse decision.

dst
I'm not saying they stadia are going to be full but you're talking as if attendances are going to be like what they are now in the WC...
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (dst @ Jan 14 2011, 05:48 PM) *
I'm not saying they stadia are going to be full but you're talking as if attendances are going to be like that in the WC...

3k, if that's true that's crazy though. It's going to have to improve drastically to come anywhere near what other countries could offer.
Ry4n
It's playing in Doha end of story and if its in winter this is why it should be.

Now comming from an englishman I would think the England managment would love it to be in January lets forget about tradition for a second and all the matches that are played at christmas and look it from the managerial point of view.In January the Premier league is in full swing am i right. Right so most of the games are played then , so the players should be in prime form scoring goals , assisting doing what they all do magnificently.....so you would think everyone in England would love this oportunity for there being no excuses from the England camp and England not to fail like we've been doing since 1966 , i would like us to reach the final for once. We can't have the same old excuse the Premier League is to long and tiresome the players are tired the weather is to hot blah blah blah NO MORE !!!!! This is why it is great for it to be held in January for England's purpose the most and the rest of Europe that don't stop in winter. So make the Premier league run on a little long into the summer and hey maybe the smaller clubs will get more people comming to see them play that would'nt do normally because of the weather. We know how it can get in winter in England and Europe you just have to look at this winters weather.....so seeing how if the league runs longer the weather will be better prompting more people to come out. just a little suggestion on how this could be good for England primarily and consequently Europe aswell. So it looks more increasingly likely it will be played in January where the weather will be perfect.
Ry4n
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jan 14 2011, 09:27 PM) *
Plus if it's moved to January then people will find it difficult to travel there, prices in the winter are ridiculous.

What about Asia , Africa , South America , North America there all comming aswell and they ain't getting there any cheaper its called saving laugh.gif
Ry4n
QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Jan 14 2011, 09:49 PM) *
3k, if that's true that's crazy though. It's going to have to improve drastically to come anywhere near what other countries could offer.

They will improve them drastically there building whole new stadio's just wait and see wink.gif
Milan Are Brilliant
This really isn't about England, how can I judge 11 years down the line how we are going to be? We could be Spain, we could be San Marino.

About the league situation wouldn't it need to be longer than a month, I mean normally with a WC you have a few weeks off before, and obviously a while off after. Players have families too, they are humans, they are real people just like you & I. Yes they get paid a lot (as fans we allow them this) but they work damn hard on the pitch and off and the only time they really get off is the summer period (in Europe) obviously off seasons differ.

I'm talking about facts here at the moment, if what Kurt says is right and only 3 thousand people are turning up, that's pitiful.

About building new stadiums, how will that make a difference? Or are these grounds only capable of holding 3 thousand at the moment? (I haven't been watching). That's like saying Torquay will build an 80,000 seater then we're certain of selling out every game.
Ry4n
QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Jan 14 2011, 10:04 PM) *
This really isn't about England, how can I judge 11 years down the line how we are going to be? We could be Spain, we could be San Marino.

About the league situation wouldn't it need to be longer than a month, I mean normally with a WC you have a few weeks off before, and obviously a while off after. Players have families too, they are humans, they are real people just like you & I. Yes they get paid a lot (as fans we allow them this) but they work damn hard on the pitch and off and the only time they really get off is the summer period (in Europe) obviously off seasons differ.

I'm talking about facts here at the moment, if what Kurt says is right and only 3 thousand people are turning up, that's pitiful.

About building new stadiums, how will that make a difference? Or are these grounds only capable of holding 3 thousand at the moment? (I haven't been watching). That's like saying Torquay will build an 80,000 seater then we're certain of selling out every game.

Dude are'nt we talking about January lol of course they will go home and see there family god for bid they don't get to the WC should be after christmas not before christmas. I'm not sure about the capacity of the stadiums they are building but they should be under FIFA Regulations and hold the right amount for any WC cup game , so i can only go on the recent size of the stadium in South Africa to go by the size they should be building them in Qatar but this is in 2022 so they have plenty of time. lol thats abit exageratted about England being like San Marino in 11 years isn't it ? yes we could be like Spain and i hope for that of course king.gif
Milan Are Brilliant
Yes, talking about January, but if you're delaying the league then that time needs to be put back into the season at the end of it, if like it should be the players get a few weeks rest either side. That means the summer will be incredibly short, in time for the next season. The only way I can see it working is to either scrap domestic cups for a season, or play 1 team once. Sounds ridiculous but I think this is going to have a knock on effect for years otherwise.
kurtsimonw
The issue with January is that it has a knock-on effect. The season won't be finishing until about July, then a 2 months break will mean the next season won't be starting until September, the following season will then be finishing late, etc. It'll then mean the Euros probably has to be delayed and the knock-on effect continues.

QUOTE (Ry4n @ Jan 14 2011, 05:53 PM) *
What about Asia , Africa , South America , North America there all comming aswell and they ain't getting there any cheaper its called saving laugh.gif

My point wasn't about just us, that's my point. Winter travel prices are more expensive because people want sun, that means people have to save more than they would usually, plus it's at a difficult time of year. Qatar won't get anywhere near the usual amount of people coming into the country that most World Cups get.

QUOTE (Ry4n @ Jan 14 2011, 06:02 PM) *
They will improve them drastically there building whole new stadio's just wait and see wink.gif

I don't see how that will make a difference. I don't think only 3k people turned up because of the stadium they were in, it's just the area obviously doesn't have a big interest in football.

The none-host games are averaging 7k, it's disgraceful to be honest. One of the things said about them getting the World Cup was "We host the Asian Cup next year, we'll show you we can host a tournement".. they've proven the opposite.

I'd like it to be a good World Cup, but it doesn't look that way at the moment and they're basically having to reshape football to give it to them.
Ry4n
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jan 14 2011, 10:32 PM) *
The issue with January is that it has a knock-on effect. The season won't be finishing until about July, then a 2 months break will mean the next season won't be starting until September, the following season will then be finishing late, etc. It'll then mean the Euros probably has to be delayed and the knock-on effect continues.


My point wasn't about just us, that's my point. Winter travel prices are more expensive because people want sun, that means people have to save more than they would usually, plus it's at a difficult time of year. Qatar won't get anywhere near the usual amount of people coming into the country that most World Cups get.


I don't see how that will make a difference. I don't think only 3k people turned up because of the stadium they were in, it's just the area obviously doesn't have a big interest in football.

The none-host games are averaging 7k, it's disgraceful to be honest. One of the things said about them getting the World Cup was "We host the Asian Cup next year, we'll show you we can host a tournement".. they've proven the opposite.

I'd like it to be a good World Cup, but it doesn't look that way at the moment and they're basically having to reshape football to give it to them.

Don't worry about it to much its only 2011 now you should come go visit Doha before the transformation of the stadiums.
kurtsimonw
Time is definitely on their side, I agree. They've a long way to get though to try and bring up the crowds to 35k/40k average!

I'd like to visit places like that, but it's just too hot for me! Even English summers are a bit much, can't sleep or anything.
Milan Are Brilliant
I think I'm going to try and say my reasons and the whole play at January thing.

Disclaimer: I don't just care about the English league, I'm using it as an example. I don't think it's the "bestest" league in the world. And am not trying to discount other leagues. It just seems prominent as it seems to be 3 people from the UK discussing this at the moment... Ok I'll go on.

So playing in January will break up the season beyond belief, surely it wouldn't be a simple case of taking 4 weeks out, I mean isn't the WC usually over at least 30 days? The players need time off before and after no? Even if this was done in June/July they get a few weeks to prepare. Gives them time to acclimatise, get together, set up training camp, have a few practice games etc.

Now, during January as someone said is one of the busiest periods in the EPL, not only this but we have the FA Cup come into it's 3rd/4th round (where the Prem clubs become involved). How would this be caught up? Wait until the WC is over? Ok, but by the time that has happened suddenly we run into European games, where quite often 4/5 English clubs are present. What would happen if a replay would occur? We also have Carling Cup ties during this period, again the FA taking advantage of Europe not being played at this time.

On top of this nowadays when internationals are played it's rare for many Championship games to go ahead, therefore this will need to be delayed as well. Even some League 1 games have been delayed this season due to internationals.

I know people will talk about pre-season after WC being soon after but usually after an international tournament a majority of the players who have been playing in that don't even participate until the latter stages. Quite simply there wouldn't be this opportunity as these pre-season games will be full on domestic matches, that clubs need to win!

Again, the whole stadiums, being made bigger thing doesn't really make sense, if they aren't already sold out. If they aren't sold out then surely it's just the demand isn't that big, no matter what we are being told? Yes, they have time but after them getting the WC surely now would be as good a time as any to get in the game.
Ry4n
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jan 14 2011, 10:44 PM) *
Time is definitely on their side, I agree. They've a long way to get though to try and bring up the crowds to 35k/40k average!

I'd like to visit places like that, but it's just too hot for me! Even English summers are a bit much, can't sleep or anything.


Dude they have Air Conditioning everwhere and i mean everywhere even bus stops lol winter is a great time to come its like Englands summer.
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Jan 14 2011, 06:50 PM) *
So playing in January will break up the season beyond belief, surely it wouldn't be a simple case of taking 4 weeks out, I mean isn't the WC usually over at least 30 days? The players need time off before and after no? Even if this was done in June/July they get a few weeks to prepare. Gives them time to acclimatise, get together, set up training camp, have a few practice games etc.

There's 6 games in January - 8 for those that made the CCSF - then there's the possibility of an FA Cup 3rd Round replay (I believe the FA Cup 4th Round is at the end of Jan as well, so that could be another game or 2!). So you are looking at the possibility of 10 games having to be re-scheduled. This is of course, as you said, without taking into consideration the acclimatising and training periods the squads will need.

You could be looking at re-scheduling around 15 games. If you take into account that the players would have been playing pretty much none-stop from August to the World Cup and then afterwards, you'd have to spread the games out. Expecting them to play pretty much twice a week for an entire year is too much. 15 games would take 3 months to sort out, so you're looking at the season finishing in August. Then the players would need a break, because they've been paying for an entire year, which would mean the next season wouldn't start until end of September/October.

The following season wouldn't be finishing until around August time because of the knock-on effect. The problem with that? Where do the Euros fit in? If you stop the season to fit the Euros in, it becomes a joke, the season would be different every year and it'd probably take a decade or so of shortneded pre-season breaks to get the season back on track to it's August-May format.
dst
I really can't comprehend what you guys are talking about... they're going to move the WC to January and then the leagues will finish at the end of June/beginning of July... that's when the season stops anyway when there's a WC, what prolonged season are you talking about? unsure.gif
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (dst @ Jan 15 2011, 12:51 PM) *
I really can't comprehend what you guys are talking about... they're going to move the WC to January and then the leagues will finish at the end of June/beginning of July... that's when the season stops anyway when there's a WC, what prolonged season are you talking about? unsure.gif

It's not as easy as that for reasons I discussed above, with cups etc being played at this time of year, due to European competitions not being on. We also have quite a few public holidays this month therefore they can play more football and people will actually turn up. It's not like you can play 3pm on a normal weekday when a large majority of your fans are going to be working.

These games become mid-week games (when European competitions are on) thus a number of clubs will need to play and catch up on these on a Saturday.

Those are a few reasons. It's not simply a case of we make up the time elsewhere, thus the season isn't getting extended.
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (dst @ Jan 15 2011, 12:51 PM) *
I really can't comprehend what you guys are talking about... they're going to move the WC to January and then the leagues will finish at the end of June/beginning of July... that's when the season stops anyway when there's a WC, what prolonged season are you talking about? unsure.gif

Come on, you're a smart guy.

The World Cup is usually played in June, at the end of the season, where you play a maximum of 7 games over a month.

If it's moved to January, at least in England, you're looking at having to re-schedule around an average of 12 games for each team because it's a busy time over here. I don't think it'd be fair after having been playing football for so long to expect the players to play those 12 games within a month period. It's alright in January to do so because it's mid-season, the players aren't going to be tired. But after having played for 10 months, it's not really realistic to have them playing twice a week for 6 straight weeks.

As Ash said, you can't really re-schedule them due to Cup/Europe mid-week games.

It's really not as simple as just putting the World Cup in January either, do you really think all the national teams will want no time together for a few weeks before hand? It could possibly take up 2 months of the season, not just 1. Which would mean the season would finish closer to August - when the next season is meant to start.
dst
I don't think the players are happier playing at the WC in June after those long seasons they have nowadays so I doubt they'll find it more tiresome. Especially since as you said, the schedule at the WC is not as tight which means they'll actually be less tired at the end of January (or whenever the WC will end) than they'd be normally. I still can't see how it will be prolonged for more than a week. And I add that week as a resting period right after the WC which I don't think is much needed anyway because of the looser schedule we talked about. Otherwise it's just pause and then resume and the season will still end around where it should in a WC year only with a harder last month than usual. We'll have to see what they'll come up with but I doubt it will be a problem. I can't see the players having a problem with it, I actually believe most of them will enjoy being at the top of their game representing their country instead of being dead tired as it has been. I see more trouble coming from their clubs because you'll certainly have some injuries and they won't be happy to lose any of their players for the remainder of the season.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2026 Invision Power Services, Inc.