QUOTE (Zed.D @ Oct 21 2010, 12:46 PM)

I've been thinking, how can someone who's won 2 consecutive Serie A manager of the season titles (by the votes of his fellow league coaches, mind you) be so clueless about something so obvious. do we - MF members - really understand football better than the guy? that's a question we all got to ask ourselves IMO. maybe he's been taking orders from above as to how and who to play? good thing is, we'll know that as soon as October 25. after the Madrid debacle there simply is no reason why he should continue using the same players and not make any radical and permanent changes in the lineup, unless he really is clueless.
But then again, there's his substitutions which rarely make much sense. how can you be a good coach, but make useless and even disruptive substitutions? what do you think about this?
Well when taking into consideration the complexion of the squad when Allegri took over, I can see why it would be very difficult for him to make wholesale changes to the team immediately. Before
any new coach taking the helm of a team can implement a his views — especially when it is a relatively young coach who doesn't command the immediate respect of the players (regardless of the players' reputations) like a Mourinho, SAF, and Hiddink would — needs the whole-hearted support of the dressing room. And at Milan, that means he needs the support of the dressing room pillars: two of which are Seedorf and Rino. If Allegri came in immediately and relegated Seedorf and Rino to the bench from the start (players who command respect for their past achievements regardless of their current form), it would have created cracks in the dressing room identity before he knew it — especially with all the new players we had — and possibly undermined any of his efforts. Those guys, despite being past their primes, after all these years have integrated themselves into the identity of who we are as a team.
Therefore, one can sort of see why it was necessary for Allegri to defer to the old guard at first. However, once optimal results are not being attained however — which is what we are seeing slowly but surely — the mediocre results would justify the changes. It is here, at this point, where Allegri would be well within his right in changing the complexion of the team in favor of a winning formula. If he got that formula correct, and the team started winning with the likes of Seedorf and Rino on the bench, then should they let their egos out of check, they'd run the risk of looking selfish and further diminish their good graces.
When you look at the example of Man U, SAF has been able to transition a newer generation in a relatively smooth fashion because the team never experienced a severe drop off when Scholes and Giggs would start on the bench. When Nani and say Gibson started ahead of them, SAF gave both the youngsters confidence by selecting them. At the same time, they understood they were on a short leash, because if they didn't, then the likes of Giggs and Scholes subbing in for them would be completely understood by the youngsters, and the two veterans would still be made to feel important.
However, because of the combination of 1)pressure that the egos of veterans Seedorf and Rino create for Max, and 2) the fact that he doesn't have the 'listen or get out' aura of a Hiddink, SAF or Jose, if he doesn't get his reshuffle correct quickly, there's always that chance that he'll lose the support of the veterans he drops at any time. Therefore, as far as dressing room stability goes, there's always that fine line for him as long as they are here - and apprehension to risk that is understandable.
That's why, despite the obvious changes we here feel he should make, it's tougher for him. He's the one who has to look at Seedorf and Rino in the face every day, and deal with the ripple effects that their egos would have upon team morale.
For this reason, I am compelled to grant Allegri patience. HOWEVER, that point where playing the old guard yields mediocre results is NOW. After the Madrid performances, with the murders row of matches we have coming up, and all the talent in the squad at his disposal, now is the time for Max to make his changes, make them correctly, and truly establish himself as in control of the team. If he doesn't, then we know he's not the man for the job.
Regarding his substitutions though? The blame for these fall on nobody but him. And for this, his leash in my eyes has shortened. When SAF transitions the new-gen in, his substitutions are always timely. If he sees something that he thinks will compromise the result of that very game, then he'll make his change in the first half if he has to. Allegri has sadly not shown that same competence..
Managing Milan is different from managing Cagliari in that at Milan, the coach almost has to prove himself to the players that he can win. At Cagliari, most of the players are happy to be in Serie A, focused only on trying to impress you no matter who you are, and without ego, trying to crack the starting XI. Allegri was surely a shrewd manager of Cagliari, and made the most of his situation there. However, the ego management aspect of managing big clubs is something he's unaccustomed to, and a factor that will ultimately make or break his time here over this next month.
If the above cited article is to be believed, and we see something resembling the lineups that Dracoris and/or Han posted earlier, then Allegri will earn himself more patience out the likes of myself...