[Zed.D]

I want to see it again because I didn't watch the replays but even in real-time it looked like a huge gift

That was plain and simply a TRAVESTY. let's face it, we've been given many unfair penalties before but this one was out of this world. absolutely scandalous and Udinese players had every right to confront the ref like that after the FT.

[KillerMax]

Dam Ref! Discussion of Milan match fixing will come up again i guess.... Crazy decision..!!

And to think the ref was switched kind of last minute... (IMG:style_emoticons/default/unsure.gif)

[X-Offender]

It's a 50-50 to me. There was contact definitely. We'll see what Moviola will tell us.

Yeah, I feel the same. The Udinese player seemed to take the ball, but he also shoved El Shaarawy to the ground.

This post has been edited by X-Offender: Feb 3 2013, 10:44 PM

[Milan Are Brilli...]

Ridiculous decision. Robbed them in all honesty. Hard to enjoy that

[Fillipo Simone]

Can't even enjoy the victory. Feel sorry of Udinese... (IMG:style_emoticons/default/sleep.gif)

Why? This is a deserved win, let's take the 3 and move along.

[Bluesummers]

he won the ball, end of story. He got contact with the ball before the player. No penalty.

[KillerMax]

Why? This is a deserved win, let's take the 3 and move along.

I agree we perhaps deserved the win, but not like this. Just feels heavy on the chest.

[han2503]

So, you all think it wasn't a penalty?

Never a penalty

Even watching it in realtime you could easily tell that he took the ball cleanly before SES fell. Shocking but I'll take it considering all the terrible calls happening in Serie A. I'm sure we'll suffer an unjust decision in another game to even out this one

It's a 50-50 to me. There was contact definitely. We'll see what Moviola will tell us.

Don't think it was 50-50 at all. 100% clean tackle, never a foul. Seems like the ref decided to grab some headlines today

[X-Offender]

Why? This is a deserved win, let's take the 3 and move along.

Absolutely. I don't give a damn about the penalty. What matters are the 3 points, travesty or not.

[Zed.D]

Not blaming El Sha for diving, but I wish he had the dignity to tell the ref it wasn't a penalty. but again, not pointing fingers at him.

[Jack Bauer]

he won the ball, end of story. He got contact with the ball before the player. No penalty.

yeah, pretty much.

But mistakes happen, it's part of the game. How many time we were robbed last season?

[han2503]

I agree we perhaps deserved the win, but not like this. Just feels heavy on the chest.

A deserved win?

Nah...

A shocking second half. If we're going on the first half performance then sure. But a match is 90 minutes long not just 45.

It's really worrying how mentally fragile this team is. Absolutely fell apart once that ball went in

[kurtsimonw]

That was plain and simply a TRAVESTY. let's face it, we've been given many unfair penalties before but this one was out of this world. absolutely scandalous and Udinese players had every right to confront the ref like that after the FT.

And what will happen? Udinese will probably have a fine, the ref will continue doing his job as normal and the Italian FA will do nothing about it. Football really is completely broken to be honest.

[Bluesummers]

we were lucky, but lets take the 3 points and move on. God knows it could have been much worst against udinese.

[kurtsimonw]

Not blaming El Sha for diving, but I wish he had the dignity to tell the ref it wasn't a penalty. but again, not pointing fingers at him.

Nah it weren't a dive. It was a strong tackle and he clearly unbalanced SES, but he got 100% of the ball first.