I wouldn't say I'd be thrilled to sell him, but if it opened up funds for other areas in our side and someone offered £30m+ I'd probably take that. With the view being based on we'd still keep Robinho, Zlatan etc.

Ibra, Tevez, Robinho, Cassano. We'd still have a world class attack.

For starters, it makes him a hypocrite. Pato doesn't like that Max went to the media instead of him, so what does he do? Answers back in the media, instead of saying it to Max.

In my opinion, it's part of Max's job to talk to the media about his players and as coach and a superior there's nothing wrong with that. I don't think a player should go directly to the media and say stuff about his coach. This guys for Ambro, Zlatan, Pato, anyone.


I'd personally drive him to the buying team at that price!

look i think if we lived without kaka then we can live without pato…now isn’t the right time to sell him since its january and if tevez were to come he wouldn’t be able to play the champions league..but i think if from now until then end of the season if pato doesn’t progress then we should take the 50 million..i mean 50 million is a lot of money for a guy who plays 20 games a season and only plays well in 10 of them…what i say is take the money and use it to fix other areas of the team, like i said before if we lived without sheva and kaka then we can definitely live without pato..
i dunno if u guys would agree though

All thing considered - Yes.

I think Pato has more to give, he has yet to reach his prime. However, i would send even T Silva out the door for €50MM. It would only be right to consider such valuations, especially when your considering UEFA's FFP in the same light.

Galliani would send Pato directly to Paris.

So far it's 6-0 for yes. Nice.

Yes, if that means that Balotelli will replace him.

What makes you guys think we can sell him for 50 million euros? talk about living in cloud cuckoo land!


I don't think anyone will argue with you on that we can live without Pato. the arguments are not about that, but about how you treat and under which circumstances you sell your valuable players.

This post has been edited by Zed.D: Dec 28 2011, 06:02 PM

Make that 7-0 because in theory I would too. lame game though (IMG:style_emoticons/default/biggrin.gif)

Because that's PSG's offer. Remember, they signed Pastore for €43 million, and he's nobody compared to Pato.



Now, now, you wouldn't sell him even if they offered us Messi and Ronaldo in one packet. (IMG:style_emoticons/default/tongue.gif)

Tevez > Balotelli.

Eh Balotelli is younger and italian.. and his a brighter future. Safe to say they both have baggage

Could there be a better time than now to sell Pato? Regardless of anyones opinions on him, how often does a team have an opportunity to sell a player for big money and it won't even affect their on field performances? Obviously City can do that with Tevez, but it's rare such a thing can happen.

Though you can never judge a transfer until a few years after it has happened, depends how wisely you spend the money.

I know about PSG's offer, I just don't think Pato would agree to go there because it would be a huge step-down for him as a footballer. the only way I can see him leaving is a club of equal status to Milan's making that offer (and I'm ignoring his words about leaving Milan only for Barca).

Well, not against his will! but if he was happy, why not?