[Zed.D]

Tough game at San Paolo. really tough! I hope Max has learned his lessons from last night's game.. in other words


TIME TO GIVE ZEE, RINO AND DINHO SOME REST!!

START KPB, MATHIEU AND BINHO INSTEAD.




































Please! (IMG:style_emoticons/default/unsure.gif)

[Fillipo Simone]

Maybe I didn't express myself properly. Maybe not overrated, but Flamini and Boateng are barely tested and I see no reason why I should belive in them so much.

[X-Offender]

Maybe I didn't express myself properly. Maybe not overrated, but Flamini and Boateng are barely tested and I see no reason why I should belive in them so much.

Should we keep believing in Seedorf and Gattuso then? (IMG:style_emoticons/default/wink.gif)

[vnata001]

Should we keep believing in Seedorf and Gattuso then? (IMG:style_emoticons/default/wink.gif)

Fillipo, can you please offer a response to this question?

You say you don't trust them because they aren't tested. Well then doesn't that logically beg the question: Why not test them to see if we can trust them? You've seen the results when we've played our "tested" players.

And this term "Milan quality" really needs to be dissected a little bit. How can you be making claims that Flamini is not "Milan quality" when you admit that our coaches haven't given him a chance? Not too long ago, Flamini was "Arsenal quality" and that Arsenal side in which he played an important role in romped all over our "Milan quality" in the San Siro under the Carlo the great, no less.

The "milan quality" you want would involve breaking the bank for pastore and hamsik. We're not going to do that. And we need not look any further than the RESULTS of the coaches whose keen eye for talent you site in your rationale as to why Flamini isn't worth the fuss. Its the same bunch that overplayed Emerson and Brocchi, failed the talents of Gourcuff and Hunter, and have overseen our team during a 3 year period of relative mediocrity. Obviously for all their trusty talent-appraising abilities, they certainly have not always been right. They are not above criticism.

Some of us in the forum have been calling it as its happened over the years, and what's happening now with Seedorf and Rino is no different from previous instances of mismanagement.

This post has been edited by vnata001: Oct 21 2010, 06:24 AM

[acid911]

Fillipo, can you please offer a response to this question?

You say you don't trust them because they aren't tested. Well then doesn't that logically beg the question: Why not test them to see if we can trust them? You've seen the results when we've played our "tested" players.

And this term "Milan quality" really needs to be dissected a little bit. How can you be making claims that Flamini is not "Milan quality" when you admit that our coaches haven't given him a chance? Not too long ago, Flamini was "Arsenal quality" and that Arsenal side in which he played an important role in romped all over our "Milan quality" in the San Siro under the Carlo the great, no less.

The "milan quality" you want would involve breaking the bank for pastore and hamsik. We're not going to do that. And we need not look any further than the RESULTS of the coaches whose keen eye for talent you site in your rationale as to why Flamini isn't worth the fuss. Its the same bunch that overplayed Emerson and Brocchi, failed the talents of Gourcuff and Hunter, and have overseen our team during a 3 year period of relative mediocrity. Obviously for all their trusty talent-appraising abilities, they certainly have not always been right. They are not above criticism.

Some of us in the forum have been calling it as its happened over the years, and what's happening now with Seedorf and Rino is no different from previous instances of mismanagement.

Oh boy, you're in great form, vnata! (IMG:style_emoticons/default/king.gif) Awesome post once again, and love the shoutout to 'Carlo teh Great'.

And frankly though there is no such thing as Milan quality. It existed a few years back, when we could stand hand to head with other big clubs and matched them blow for blow (if not in spending prowess, then on the pitch). (IMG:style_emoticons/default/smile.gif) Now we can't even gather steam, let alone run out of it. And the reason for that is a disjointed team. Remember what I said a few months back, that B&G just plastered the squad by bringing in Ibra and Robino. The underlying problems and cracks are still there.

And they will, unless we get adequate replacements next season or two. They missed a trick by missing out on VdV, Hernanes, and Krasic. Frankly I'd have taken any of those three as opposed to Robinho (good player I know, but I've got a feeling he may under deliver). Robin is cover for our attackers, not the answer to our problems: the aging midfield and the static right flank.