Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Summer Transfers 2022
AC Milan - Milanfan.com > AC Milan > Transfers
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Jul 28 2022, 03:52 PM) *
Just get it over with already! The most tiring and bothersome transfer saga since I've been a Milan fan.

Amen to that. Felt like I was on a hamster wheel with ever step supposedly being the decisive step forward that lead to nowhere rolleyes.gif

QUOTE (X-Offender @ Jul 29 2022, 01:12 PM) *
CDK is finally done. Player is expected in Milan between tonight and tomorrow.

FINALLY!!!

Hallelulja!!


QUOTE (X-Offender @ Jul 29 2022, 08:40 PM) *
It's a bargain. Players like De Ketelaere are being paid insane money nowadays. Just think that Man Utd signed two days ago Lisandro Martinez (who???) from Ajax for over 60m.

CDK is an extremely exciting prospect. Can't wait to see him with our colours.

Now we can also finally concentrate on signing those Romagnoli and Kessie replacements.

Agreed.

Once again, great business from Maldini and Massara. Fees for players have just become insane and simply unsustainable for Serie A clubs who are cursed as members of a terribly run organization. Thankfully we managed to get this done, even when there was a club like f@cking Leeds who were offering over 40m and a better salary to the player
X-Offender
Starting and secondary line-ups thus far:

Maignan
Calabria - Kalulu - Tomori - Theo
Tonali - Bennacer
CDK - Adli - Leao
Origi

Tatarusanu
Florenzi - Kjaer - Gabbia - Toure
Pobega - Krunic
Messias - Brahim - Rebic
Giroud


Plus Mirante, Bakayoko, Saelemaekers, Zlatan and Lazetic.

We obviously need to sign a CB (Tanganga and Ndicka being the primary names) and a DM (this Chukuwuemeka kid being linked the most).
han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Jul 29 2022, 09:21 PM) *
Starting and secondary line-ups thus far:

Maignan
Calabria - Kalulu - Tomori - Theo
Tonali - Bennacer
CDK - Adli - Leao
Origi

Tatarusanu
Florenzi - Kjaer - Gabbia - Toure
Pobega - Krunic
Messias - Brahim - Rebic
Giroud


Plus Mirante, Bakayoko, Saelemaekers, Zlatan and Lazetic.

We obviously need to sign a CB (Tanganga and Ndicka being the primary names) and a DM (this Chukuwuemeka kid being linked the most).


Midfield and CB areas obviously a big worry, Have to replace Romagnoli and Kessie ASAP. And injury and we're completely derailed
Rossoneri7
Both a CB and a CDM will be brought in. The targets identified and Maldini/Massara are discussing/negotiating behind the scenes.

This CDK soap opera teaches us an important lesson in how they go about their business. I would not expect them to act on impulse. They have a main target and a fall safe target. They know what elements is needed in building this team as they know what the coach needs.

The more I zoom out and look in I see teams like inter digging deep holes in their balance sheet, while Milan are building a fortress of a balance sheet.

I like the way the dup are working.

@han Re- Messias signing, I honestly believe he deserves it. He is a player that doesn?t complain, keeps his head down and works for the team. Last year he was an outsider, this year he will be very much familiar with how to team functions and will be an asset for sure in providing quality/depth. Not a ballon d?or contender for sure but a great option to have coming off the bench.

Sales? I think with Kessie, Romagnoli, and Castillejo gone Milan have done enough. Saelemakers isn?t that bad, I don?t mind him at all. And now with CDK and Origi, he has a small Belgian community going for him. He most definitely will come in handy if you clock in the amount of games the be played + injury/fatigue factor. He would give that additional cushion for squad rotation. Don?t think Milan will be shipping him off. Even if Ziyech does come.
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Jul 29 2022, 09:41 PM) *
Midfield and CB areas obviously a big worry, Have to replace Romagnoli and Kessie ASAP. And injury and we're completely derailed


The good thing is though that as far as the starting line-up is concerned we're fine. I think that's a very strong formation, especially since our weakest areas from last season (RW, AM and CF) have been strengthened with higher quality alternatives.

Kalulu-Tomori have shown to be a top class pairing. I actually expect Kalulu to improve even further. Bennacer-Tonali for me was always the way to go in midfield since last season. Adli is everything Brahim hasn't been for us. Origi has the quality to do much better than Giroud. And obviously CDK is the icing on the cake.

I have a very good feeling about this season. But obviously we need to complete the squad with those Romagnoli and Kessie replacements. They don't even need to be marquee signings, just decent backups. I'd be perfectly fine with Tanganga/Ndicka and Chukwuemeka, for instance.
han2503
QUOTE (Rossoneri7 @ Jul 30 2022, 01:24 AM) *
Both a CB and a CDM will be brought in. The targets identified and Maldini/Massara are discussing/negotiating behind the scenes.

This CDK soap opera teaches us an important lesson in how they go about their business. I would not expect them to act on impulse. They have a main target and a fall safe target. They know what elements is needed in building this team as they know what the coach needs.

The more I zoom out and look in I see teams like inter digging deep holes in their balance sheet, while Milan are building a fortress of a balance sheet.

I like the way the dup are working.

@han Re- Messias signing, I honestly believe he deserves it. He is a player that doesn?t complain, keeps his head down and works for the team. Last year he was an outsider, this year he will be very much familiar with how to team functions and will be an asset for sure in providing quality/depth. Not a ballon d?or contender for sure but a great option to have coming off the bench.

Sales? I think with Kessie, Romagnoli, and Castillejo gone Milan have done enough. Saelemakers isn?t that bad, I don?t mind him at all. And now with CDK and Origi, he has a small Belgian community going for him. He most definitely will come in handy if you clock in the amount of games the be played + injury/fatigue factor. He would give that additional cushion for squad rotation. Don?t think Milan will be shipping him off. Even if Ziyech does come.

Agreed re the operations of the club. Smart business ever since Maldini and Massara took over, not to mention the scouting team behind them lead by Moncada.

Inter and Juve are obviously trying to do what they can for instant success. The fact that we won the league shows that our way is the right one. Not to mention that, as you said, they're digging themselves into financial holes. Especially Inter who don't have Exor behind them to inject capital when needed

As for Messias, sure the story of his rise inspires romanticism, but we cannot base our transfer strategy on how beautiful a player's story is. I like both Alexis and Messias in their own way, but the quality gap between our starter and back ups simply shouldn't be that huge. With Ziyech he'd arguably be better than CDK as of right now. Most CL teams have 2 starting quality teams, for me it is not good enough that we'll have Messias and Alexis as direct back ups to a very young player who's going to have a lot of pressure put on hi to perform instantly.

QUOTE (X-Offender @ Jul 30 2022, 11:18 AM) *
The good thing is though that as far as the starting line-up is concerned we're fine. I think that's a very strong formation, especially since our weakest areas from last season (RW, AM and CF) have been strengthened with higher quality alternatives.

Kalulu-Tomori have shown to be a top class pairing. I actually expect Kalulu to improve even further. Bennacer-Tonali for me was always the way to go in midfield since last season. Adli is everything Brahim hasn't been for us. Origi has the quality to do much better than Giroud. And obviously CDK is the icing on the cake.

I have a very good feeling about this season. But obviously we need to complete the squad with those Romagnoli and Kessie replacements. They don't even need to be marquee signings, just decent backups. I'd be perfectly fine with Tanganga/Ndicka and Chukwuemeka, for instance.

But with the schedule we'll have we cannot think of it like this. The midfield pivot atm is a major issue. We need a player on the same level as Bennacer and Tonali, that's why I have been so tied to the Sanches stuff, because he is just that. Pobega, Krunic, Bakayoko, this is the same issue I've talked about above re the RW and AM positions, you cannot go 10 steps down the quality ladder when you introduce a sub or have to rotate. Plus, I think a more physical player like Kessie was is important to add to the mix there as Benna-Tonali are not always the ideal pivot partnership against certain teams. As things stand, as soon as we rotate that midfield the quality falls off a cliff. And that is a big worry, And the Aston Villa kid is highly rated so I would be okay with him (sort of) being the signing, but I would be much more comfortable with a ready made player here. Because if either Benna or Tonali are out we could be in trouble. The CB are is not as precarious, because there is Kjaer already as a back up. So whoever comes in is not under instant pressure and has to start a good amount of games
X-Offender
Renato would have been perfect, but I repeat that for me that ship has sailed. No other names are being mentioned right now, so the Aston Villa kid seems the most plausible option. There was also a rumor regarding Fratesi a couple of weeks ago, a player I highly rate, but nothing has been mentioned ever since.

Diallo is being mentioned again for the defence. Honestly he would be perfect. Experienced, left-footed, can play as LB so we'd also be solving the vice-Theo issue. Let's see if PSG are willing to give him up on loan.
X-Offender
Sanches to PSG confirmed late last night, right after Roma had agreed terms with Wijnaldum.

As I have always been saying, PSG was just waiting to free up space, and Sanches was just a matter of time for them.

Good for him and us as well. I would never want a player that prefers that pathetic club over us.

Chukwemeka to Chelesa is also official.

So, in a single day we lost both our targets. Curious to see who we'll go after now.
han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 3 2022, 08:38 AM) *
Sanches to PSG confirmed late last night, right after Roma had agreed terms with Wijnaldum.

As I have always been saying, PSG was just waiting to free up space, and Sanches was just a matter of time for them.

Good for him and us as well. I would never want a player that prefers that pathetic club over us.

Chukwemeka to Chelesa is also official.

So, in a single day we lost both our targets. Curious to see who we'll go after now.

Disappointing that he'd push to go to a club that doesn't even celebrate winning the league. And CL success is the only factor that defines whether a season is a success or not. They booed Messi FFS after winning the league

Anyway good luck to him, no hard feelings. PSG were offering him a better deal so can't fault him there.

This does leave us in a bit of a pickle though. We really need an extra mid. I really don't know who that coul be at this point.
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 3 2022, 09:50 AM) *
Disappointing that he'd push to go to a club that doesn't even celebrate winning the league. And CL success is the only factor that defines whether a season is a success or not. They booed Messi FFS after winning the league

Anyway good luck to him, no hard feelings. PSG were offering him a better deal so can't fault him there.

This does leave us in a bit of a pickle though. We really need an extra mid. I really don't know who that coul be at this point.


He's a mercenary. He's been playing with his salary demands for months. We would have signed him since May had he accepted our offer. Now his old mentors go to PSG and he takes the bait like a b*tch in heat. F*ck him. I hope, and I'm sure that he will fail there.
Rossoneri7
It is somewhat of a disappointment, but nevertheless I believe Maldini and co have shortlisted names for midfield. They work behind closed doors and have not commented on any rumor thus far, which makes me feel at ease that what they got cooking is a player that adds value to the team.

Plus, I believe Bennacer should be given a first team role and the incoming player someone who rotates with Tonali and Bennacer. So in a way, I see Sanches not coming as giving more responsibilities to our Algerian talent.
X-Offender
QUOTE (Rossoneri7 @ Aug 3 2022, 11:18 AM) *
Plus, I believe Bennacer should be given a first team role and the incoming player someone who rotates with Tonali and Bennacer. So in a way, I see Sanches not coming as giving more responsibilities to our Algerian talent.


This, one million times.

Whoever comes as Kessie's replacement should be someone reliable but willing to warm the bench for the majority of the games. Tonali-Bennacer is our future.
X-Offender
Anyway, I'm not worried about our mercato anymore. Yes, we do need a couple of signings to complete the roster, but we already have a quality starting line-up and quality alternatives in most roles. Adli, CDK and Origi will make a difference.
han2503
I'd prefer someone of higher quality than that though. Last season we had 3 starter level players. So by saying you want someone who is just there to rotate and is willing to warm the bench you're accepting that the quality of the squad will go down

And if either Sandro or Benna get injured then we have issues. Because the guy we brought in is going to cause a dip in quality, one that was not there last season. I'd personally prefer if we go all in for the position and get that type of profile for the CB position because in that area we have 3 starting quality players for 2 positions while in midfield it's 2 for 2. I really don't want to see Spurs rejects or any other random name just so we can say we signed someone. If that's the case than we van just stick with Krunic, Pobega and Baka because it's not going to make that much of a difference
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 3 2022, 12:55 PM) *
I'd prefer someone of higher quality than that though. Last season we had 3 starter level players. So by saying you want someone who is just there to rotate and is willing to warm the bench you're accepting that the quality of the squad will go down

And if either Sandro or Benna get injured then we have issues. Because the guy we brought in is going to cause a dip in quality, one that was not there last season. I'd personally prefer if we go all in for the position and get that type of profile for the CB position because in that area we have 3 starting quality players for 2 positions while in midfield it's 2 for 2. I really don't want to see Spurs rejects or any other random name just so we can say we signed someone. If that's the case than we van just stick with Krunic, Pobega and Baka because it's not going to make that much of a difference


We have no money, man. Budget was reportedly 55-60 mil and we've already spent 40 for CDK, Florenzi and Messias.

Sanches was a bargain because he would be coming for 15 mil, but it's impossible to find someone of that quality for that much money.

Besides, I didn't mean to sign someone of scarce quality (otherwise we already have Pobega and Krunic), but someone who is willing to accept less playing time. Last year Kessie played a lot because Pioli was fixated with him and Bennacer was injured for many games. But personally I was never a fan of Kessie and I'm actually glad he's not here anymore so Isma can get more playing time.

The names of Pape Matar Sarr, Ndombele and Douglas Luiz are being thrown around now. I'd be fine with any of them (though I don't think Douglas Luiz will come).
Rossoneri7
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 3 2022, 02:32 PM) *
This, one million times.

Whoever comes as Kessie's replacement should be someone reliable but willing to warm the bench for the majority of the games. Tonali-Bennacer is our future.


Indeed!

And that type of player is available, who the player is is a mystery to only us. I have a conviction that Maldini and co have a shortlist of players they like. A CB and CDM will be added I believe, be that loan or outright purchase, that is a technicality the club has to manage. However for us fans, the mercato is still open and who knows what their next move could be.
han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 3 2022, 01:21 PM) *
We have no money, man. Budget was reportedly 55-60 mil and we've already spent 40 for CDK, Florenzi and Messias.

Sanches was a bargain because he would be coming for 15 mil, but it's impossible to find someone of that quality for that much money.

Besides, I didn't mean to sign someone of scarce quality (otherwise we already have Pobega and Krunic), but someone who is willing to accept less playing time. Last year Kessie played a lot because Pioli was fixated with him and Bennacer was injured for many games. But personally I was never a fan of Kessie and I'm actually glad he's not here anymore so Isma can get more playing time.

The names of Pape Matar Sarr, Ndombele and Douglas Luiz are being thrown around now. I'd be fine with any of them (though I don't think Douglas Luiz will come).

We don't know what the budget is, but yes it's probably tight, but we can still work something out with loan + obligation/option formula. That midfield area absolutely needs another good player there. I personally don't know how good any of those players really are, I know Ndombele was very highly rated but seemingly fell off a cliff. What Kessie brought aside from a lot of physicality to the pitch was consistency. I don't think he's missed more than 15 games total during his entire time with us. That's insane and with Benna usually having a couple of niggles each season I am worried about what happens when either him or Tonali are not available or might need to be rested.

I really hope this is not turning out to be like last summer with not replacing Hakan
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 4 2022, 08:57 PM) *
I really hope this is not turning out to be like last summer with not replacing Hakan


But last summer we replaced Hakan with his sub, i.e. Brahim. This summer we already have two quality CM's, i.e. Tonali and Bennacer. So, it's not exactly the same.
CrazyMilanFan
https://sempremilan.com/milan-juventus-kess...scape-barcelona

although unlikely but i hope he does not come to juve
X-Offender
QUOTE (CrazyMilanFan @ Aug 11 2022, 10:46 AM) *
https://sempremilan.com/milan-juventus-kess...scape-barcelona

although unlikely but i hope he does not come to juve


Nah, he'll stay and Barca. Eventually they'll find a way to register them through some sort of escamotage. But man, what's happening at Barca right now is ridiculous. I don't understand how they keep splashing such big money when they're literally on the verge of collapse.
han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 5 2022, 11:55 PM) *
But last summer we replaced Hakan with his sub, i.e. Brahim. This summer we already have two quality CM's, i.e. Tonali and Bennacer. So, it's not exactly the same.

Like I said, last season we had 3 starting quality players for those 2 positions. 1 injury this season and we're screwed. Not to mention last season Pioli rotated the 3 effectively which reduced injuries/fatigue to occur like the season prior to that. This season if we go in with just those 2 we'll have issues, as we cannot rotate and we're in trouble if we have injuries. Case in point Tonali's injury recently. If it had been what they feared we'd have lost him for a month or more. We're basically walking a tight rope.

I'd rather forego getting that CB just to make sure we bring in a good CDM. That's how critical it is to replace Kessie.

Pobega/Bakayoko/Krunic are not going to cut it. And if we have to fall back on them long term because of an injury to either Tonali or Benna then our season is f@cked. I'm 100% sure of that.

Pobega for me is another head scratcher. If Torino wanted him, we should have sold him, especially if the offer was good. He clearly isn't a player that's going to improve that much from what he currently is, and from what I've seen in pre-season against mediocre opposition, he's just not that good.
han2503
Official: Tomori renews until 2027

Great news. Fikayo is a real one for sure


Still waiting on Bennacer and Leao, we need to be concluding those ASAP. Especially Leao. He's now also nominated for a Ballon D'Or. We need to stop f@cking about with him ad meet his demands. If we let him go to next summer with his current contract we are absolutely f@cked
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 12 2022, 03:33 PM) *
Like I said, last season we had 3 starting quality players for those 2 positions. 1 injury this season and we're screwed. Not to mention last season Pioli rotated the 3 effectively which reduced injuries/fatigue to occur like the season prior to that. This season if we go in with just those 2 we'll have issues, as we cannot rotate and we're in trouble if we have injuries. Case in point Tonali's injury recently. If it had been what they feared we'd have lost him for a month or more. We're basically walking a tight rope.

I'd rather forego getting that CB just to make sure we bring in a good CDM. That's how critical it is to replace Kessie.

Pobega/Bakayoko/Krunic are not going to cut it. And if we have to fall back on them long term because of an injury to either Tonali or Benna then our season is f@cked. I'm 100% sure of that.

Pobega for me is another head scratcher. If Torino wanted him, we should have sold him, especially if the offer was good. He clearly isn't a player that's going to improve that much from what he currently is, and from what I've seen in pre-season against mediocre opposition, he's just not that good.


I know, man. Don't get me wrong. We definitely need a Kessie replacement, that goes without saying. I'm just saying that this situation is not comparable to Calhanoglu's. Two years ago we had two players for one spot (Calhanoglu, Brahim), we lost one (the starter), we didn't replace him. Last year we had three players for two spots (Kessie, Tonali, Bennacer), we lost one, insofar we haven't replaced him but nonetheless we still have two starters both of whom I rate higher than Kessie. That's the difference.
han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 12 2022, 10:17 PM) *
I know, man. Don't get me wrong. We definitely need a Kessie replacement, that goes without saying. I'm just saying that this situation is not comparable to Calhanoglu's. Two years ago we had two players for one spot (Calhanoglu, Brahim), we lost one (the starter), we didn't replace him. Last year we had three players for two spots (Kessie, Tonali, Bennacer), we lost one, insofar we haven't replaced him but nonetheless we still have two starters both of whom I rate higher than Kessie. That's the difference.

The scenarios are the same though. Kessie, whether we liked it or not, was a starter for us. Pioli generally rotated Tonali and Benna. Probably because Kessie was the physical presence in the pivot plus he rarely ever gets injured so he probably felt comfortable using him more than the others.

Like you said, the AM position we had 2 players for 1 position, and the pivot areas we had 3 players for 2 positions. And we lost a starter in both scenarios. Sure there is a difference between just have Diaz vs Tonali and Benna. But we still have to acknowledge that we're in a pickle here if we cannot properly replace Kessie.

My main reason for mentioning the Hakan case is that we let a player go for free because we're squabbling over salaries and don't want to go above a certain amount, so we're seemingly happy to keep losing players for free just so we can say we have a great salary structure, but we still have to replace these players. And never bringing in any decent transfer fees really hurts our capabilities on the market. So once again, we're stuck in a position as we were last summer, where we just lost a starter for nothing (at least this time he was decent enough not to go to Inter - f@cker), have basically no budget to operate on the market and still have a hole to fill in the squad. This is how we ended up with Messias last season, we panic bought, and now we were too nice to send him back to Crotone because he has a beautiful emergence story rolleyes.gif
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 13 2022, 10:16 PM) *
The scenarios are the same though. Kessie, whether we liked it or not, was a starter for us. Pioli generally rotated Tonali and Benna. Probably because Kessie was the physical presence in the pivot plus he rarely ever gets injured so he probably felt comfortable using him more than the others.

Like you said, the AM position we had 2 players for 1 position, and the pivot areas we had 3 players for 2 positions. And we lost a starter in both scenarios. Sure there is a difference between just have Diaz vs Tonali and Benna. But we still have to acknowledge that we're in a pickle here if we cannot properly replace Kessie.

My main reason for mentioning the Hakan case is that we let a player go for free because we're squabbling over salaries and don't want to go above a certain amount, so we're seemingly happy to keep losing players for free just so we can say we have a great salary structure, but we still have to replace these players. And never bringing in any decent transfer fees really hurts our capabilities on the market. So once again, we're stuck in a position as we were last summer, where we just lost a starter for nothing (at least this time he was decent enough not to go to Inter - f@cker), have basically no budget to operate on the market and still have a hole to fill in the squad. This is how we ended up with Messias last season, we panic bought, and now we were too nice to send him back to Crotone because he has a beautiful emergence story rolleyes.gif


But on the bright side, we won the scudetto even without Capanoglu. This season we have 3 players competing for the AM role. As for Kessie, there was nothing to be done. The guy just wanted to try something new. The salary demands, albeit important, were just a pretext to leave. The error was not selling him last summer and earn something out of it, but then again would we have won the scudetto without Kessie? Hard to say, but it goes to show you that sometimes even a bad decision might lead to something fruitful.

PS: Enough with the Messias hate, man. We get it.
han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 14 2022, 12:12 PM) *
But on the bright side, we won the scudetto even without Capanoglu. This season we have 3 players competing for the AM role. As for Kessie, there was nothing to be done. The guy just wanted to try something new. The salary demands, albeit important, were just a pretext to leave. The error was not selling him last summer and earn something out of it, but then again would we have won the scudetto without Kessie? Hard to say, but it goes to show you that sometimes even a bad decision might lead to something fruitful.

PS: Enough with the Messias hate, man. We get it.

We should have never let either the Kessie or Hakan situations get to where they did, and we are currently repeating the same pattern with Leao and Bennacer.

If a player does not want to renew we sell. Ifa renewal is not accepted before they go into the last 2 years of their contract they should be put on the market. It might hurt a bit but it's not such a huge blow as losing them for nothing


As for Messias. Sorry, have nothing against the guy, but I will continue to insist that he is not Milan quality, and the fact that we've willingly walked into another season with him as the starter and Alexis backing him is just not acceptable
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 14 2022, 09:07 PM) *
We should have never let either the Kessie or Hakan situations get to where they did, and we are currently repeating the same pattern with Leao and Bennacer.

If a player does not want to renew we sell. Ifa renewal is not accepted before they go into the last 2 years of their contract they should be put on the market. It might hurt a bit but it's not such a huge blow as losing them for nothing

As for Messias. Sorry, have nothing against the guy, but I will continue to insist that he is not Milan quality, and the fact that we've willingly walked into another season with him as the starter and Alexis backing him is just not acceptable


No club would ever decide to sell their players simply because they have two years left in their contract. One year left I can understand, but two? Never. Besides, it's not like they didn't want to renew either. Capanoglu was talking about how he was 'constantly in contact with Maldini and Massara' as late as during the Euros, whereas Kessie said during the Olympics that he would 'fix everything' as soon as he returned. It never transpired that they had no intention of renewing until it was too late, and for that we cannot blame our management.

Not to mention the insane commissions that Raiola or Atangana were demanding just for a contract renewal, and the club's policy is severely against that, as it should be. A serious club should never have to pay 10m to an agent just for renewing the contract of a player they already have.

Anyway, we've had this discussion a million times so there's no point in going back to it.

Regarding Messias, I repeat, he's a great sub to have. Much better than Saladmaker. For a starter? Nope. And I was convinced we signed CDK for the RW position, but I'm not so sure about it anymore as Pioli so far keeps placing him as AM. We really cannot have another season with only Messias and Salad on the right. It's unacceptable. Please get Ziyech, or play CDK there with Adli and Brahim fighting for the AM spot.
han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 14 2022, 11:09 PM) *
No club would ever decide to sell their players simply because they have two years left in their contract. One year left I can understand, but two? Never. Besides, it's not like they didn't want to renew either. Capanoglu was talking about how he was 'constantly in contact with Maldini and Massara' as late as during the Euros, whereas Kessie said during the Olympics that he would 'fix everything' as soon as he returned. It never transpired that they had no intention of renewing until it was too late, and for that we cannot blame our management.

Not to mention the insane commissions that Raiola or Atangana were demanding just for a contract renewal, and the club's policy is severely against that, as it should be. A serious club should never have to pay 10m to an agent just for renewing the contract of a player they already have.

Anyway, we've had this discussion a million times so there's no point in going back to it.

Regarding Messias, I repeat, he's a great sub to have. Much better than Saladmaker. For a starter? Nope. And I was convinced we signed CDK for the RW position, but I'm not so sure about it anymore as Pioli so far keeps placing him as AM. We really cannot have another season with only Messias and Salad on the right. It's unacceptable. Please get Ziyech, or play CDK there with Adli and Brahim fighting for the AM spot.

The issue with letting it go to the final year is that you lose all your negotiating power. Because a player can start talking with other clubs during that final year. Going into next summer with both Leao and Benna still on their current deals would be suicidal. That is 200m worth of assets we would be putting on the line. Players can easily say they don't want to renew and they don't want to leave in their final year, just as Kessie did. Then you are screwed. While on the final 2 years no player would risk being benched for 2 seasons so the clubs still has power in the negotiations.

I don't even consider Messias that great a sub. Let's be real here. It's not lik he's some electric player who coms on and makes the difference. Ziyech for me is a must, but having wasted 4m on Messias which could have been used as a down payment on a loan for Ziyech, I doubt we'll get him or any other winger for that matter. Which has been my issue all along with the Messias signing. Because I knew they would have seen him as the solution rather than the backup you've always said he'd be. The only smart decision with regards to Messias would have been to sign him and move him on fo some profit. Keeping him as our starter was always ridiculous
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 15 2022, 10:07 AM) *
The issue with letting it go to the final year is that you lose all your negotiating power. Because a player can start talking with other clubs during that final year. Going into next summer with both Leao and Benna still on their current deals would be suicidal. That is 200m worth of assets we would be putting on the line. Players can easily say they don't want to renew and they don't want to leave in their final year, just as Kessie did. Then you are screwed. While on the final 2 years no player would risk being benched for 2 seasons so the clubs still has power in the negotiations.

I don't even consider Messias that great a sub. Let's be real here. It's not lik he's some electric player who coms on and makes the difference. Ziyech for me is a must, but having wasted 4m on Messias which could have been used as a down payment on a loan for Ziyech, I doubt we'll get him or any other winger for that matter. Which has been my issue all along with the Messias signing. Because I knew they would have seen him as the solution rather than the backup you've always said he'd be. The only smart decision with regards to Messias would have been to sign him and move him on fo some profit. Keeping him as our starter was always ridiculous


Then let?s agree to disagree. You don?t rate Messias, I do, so let?s move on.

As for the contracts, it?s not like we?re the only club losing players on a free. Rudiger, Christensen, Alaba, Perisic, Depay, Dybala just on the top of my head. But I really don?t want to question the club?s decision for letting those contracts run out. They?re not idiots. There must be a valid, strategic reason which neither of us are aware of.
han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 15 2022, 12:26 PM) *
Then let?s agree to disagree. You don?t rate Messias, I do, so let?s move on.

As for the contracts, it?s not like we?re the only club losing players on a free. Rudiger, Christensen, Alaba, Perisic, Depay, Dybala just on the top of my head. But I really don?t want to question the club?s decision for letting those contracts run out. They?re not idiots. There must be a valid, strategic reason which neither of us are aware of.

It's not about me or you rating him though. It's about whether or not he's good enough t be a starter for a team like Milan. The Italian Champion and a CL side... He's shown us last season that's he's limited. Can be decent at times but nothing more. I just think this club needs better than the likes of Messias, there are other players that I don't think are or the right quality, but none of them are presumed to be starters by the club so it irks a lot less.

Sure, players now a days are pushing for the bosman move. Why? Because it is far more lucrative for them and their agent. Moving clubs on a free gives them endless power in negotiations. They can demand signing on bonuses, higher salaries and their agents get commissions on top of that as well. But that is why you have to be aggressive and at time ruthless as well when dealing with players who are twisting your arm. And that is why you don't let contracts dwindle to the final year.
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 15 2022, 01:55 PM) *
It's not about me or you rating him though. It's about whether or not he's good enough t be a starter for a team like Milan. The Italian Champion and a CL side... He's shown us last season that's he's limited. Can be decent at times but nothing more. I just think this club needs better than the likes of Messias, there are other players that I don't think are or the right quality, but none of them are presumed to be starters by the club so it irks a lot less.


But again, I am not disagreeing with you that Messias is not good enough to be our starter. I'm saying he has the qualities to be considered a decent sub. Now if he was signed with the intention of starting games then no, I don't agree with that. But I don't think that was the case, given our continuous interest in Ziyech for the past couple of months, and the fact CDK can very well play on the right.

QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 15 2022, 01:55 PM) *
Sure, players now a days are pushing for the bosman move. Why? Because it is far more lucrative for them and their agent. Moving clubs on a free gives them endless power in negotiations. They can demand signing on bonuses, higher salaries and their agents get commissions on top of that as well. But that is why you have to be aggressive and at time ruthless as well when dealing with players who are twisting your arm. And that is why you don't let contracts dwindle to the final year.


Like I said, there has to be a strategic reason as to why the club is letting this happen. Elliott are not a bunch of fools. They are absolute experts when it comes to finances.
han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 15 2022, 02:05 PM) *
But again, I am not disagreeing with you that Messias is not good enough to be our starter. I'm saying he has the qualities to be considered a decent sub. Now if he was signed with the intention of starting games then no, I don't agree with that. But I don't think that was the case, given our continuous interest in Ziyech for the past couple of months, and the fact CDK can very well play on the right.

Don't think CDK will be playing RW much, he's clearly seen as an AM.

We'll see if we get Ziyech or someone else. But I really do not think we'll bring in 3 more players. We're already finding it very difficult to bring in the CDM and CB we absolutely need. Even Pioli has continuously said that we're going to get the midfielder and defender, but nothing about another winger/attacker

QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 15 2022, 02:05 PM) *
Like I said, there has to be a strategic reason as to why the club is letting this happen. Elliott are not a bunch of fools. They are absolute experts when it comes to finances.

Strategy doesn't really matter when you have your hands tied. And when you go into the final year of a player's contract your hands are in fact tied. And it is all up to the player at that point
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 15 2022, 08:10 PM) *
Strategy doesn't really matter when you have your hands tied. And when you go into the final year of a player's contract your hands are in fact tied. And it is all up to the player at that point


You were the one who said we should sell any player who doesn't renew with 2 years left. But we haven't done it, and there must be a reason why management is letting these contracts run their course.

I sort of know a motive. It has to do with what adjustments are made to the financial statements of an entity when it's acquired by another entity, but I'm not gonna bore y'all with it.
han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 15 2022, 10:04 PM) *
You were the one who said we should sell any player who doesn't renew with 2 years left. But we haven't done it, and there must be a reason why management is letting these contracts run their course.

I sort of know a motive. It has to do with what adjustments are made to the financial statements of an entity when it's acquired by another entity, but I'm not gonna bore y'all with it.

Doesn't it make more sense to actually make money from your assets?

Just blows my mind that we've already let all these players go for free and could do so again with even more valuable ones...


Anyways, lots of chatter coming out of Germany that we're going for Ndicka. Honestly, this would be a great signing, and fits perfectly to our style. But If we go for him, I don't know what would be left for the midfield signing...

I've always said that we should prioritise the midfielder. And go for a serviceable defender, maybe on loan + option type deal. But Ndicka is a good opportunity for a player on his final year which we shouldn't miss out on if the fee is within reason
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 16 2022, 07:37 PM) *
Doesn't it make more sense to actually make money from your assets?

Just blows my mind that we've already let all these players go for free and could do so again with even more valuable ones...


Basically, whenever you want to sell a company, the two most important things that potential acquirers will look at are the quality of earnings, and how much debt you hold.

We currently hold no financial debt, so that is very, very positive. The quality of earnings is measured by EBITDA (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation), also known as operating profit. It shows how much profit the company is generating solely based on its operations (and that is why elements like interest, tax etc. are not looked at). Operating profit is revenues minus operating expenses, which for a football club are primarily made up by football player wages. Hence, it's imperative to control salaries as much as possible, and consequently why we impose a salary cap and don't accomodate exaggerated demands like Donnarumma or Kessie's (Ibra is the sole exception).

Another matter that is investigated during a due diligence (the process of examining the financial statements of the acquiree) is to scrap from operating profit any extraordinary or non-recurring items of profit/expenditure. These could be the profit from the sale of any asset (such as a building, machinery etc.), or in the case of football clubs, the sale of football players. That is done in order to get a better understanding of an entity's predictable annual earnings. Hence, whether we had sold Donnarumma, Kessie etc. or not, for the primary objective of Elliott, which was to gain from the club's sale, it would have made zero difference. Sure, we would obtained hard cash in return, but perhaps the club felt that Donnarumma, Calhanoglu and Kessie's contribution to the cause (be it CL access or the Scudetto) was too important to let them go prematurely. And they probably also felt that they could have renewed their contracts given the circumstances.

There is definitely more to it, I am sure, but in a nutshell I think this pretty much explains our behaviour with relation to these renewals. This way, we've managed to keep salaries below our pre-imposed cap, and with increased revenues from new sponsorship deals etc. we've also improved our quality of earnings and become self-sustainable.

Now we'll have to see what RedBird will bring to the table. If they purchased the club to make it glorious again, then I expect a gradual increase in the salary cap and more contract renewals (along with some more spending during the calciomercato).
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 16 2022, 07:37 PM) *
Anyways, lots of chatter coming out of Germany that we're going for Ndicka. Honestly, this would be a great signing, and fits perfectly to our style. But If we go for him, I don't know what would be left for the midfield signing...

I've always said that we should prioritise the midfielder. And go for a serviceable defender, maybe on loan + option type deal. But Ndicka is a good opportunity for a player on his final year which we shouldn't miss out on if the fee is within reason


This Ndicka guy seems like the real deal, I like him. Plus he's left-footed so that's a plus.

I'm sure Paolo knows what he's doing. If he's willing to spend 15m for the CB, then he already has in mind who'll be signing in midfield, which could potentially be a loan with option/obligation. We'll see.
CrazyMilanFan
i think latest on midfield is some Onyedika kid. His stats looks good and price seem to be in region which we might be able to get
X-Offender
QUOTE
@AntonioVitiello - Only a matter of time to the closing between RedBird and Elliott. The Cardinale fund will acquire 100% of the shares of Milan. The Singers will remain with a financial participation (no shareholdings), contractual arrangement for loan from the seller to the buyer.


This is great news. Elliott won't hold any minority shares in the club as it was first hypothesised, so they'll hold zero interest and zero power in decision making.
Rossoneri7
Milan seems set to keep Gabbia and with the return of Kjear, the defense is not a priority anymore.

A midfielder of a certain calibre would come in, with Bakayoko leaving the club.

han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 16 2022, 09:19 PM) *
This Ndicka guy seems like the real deal, I like him. Plus he's left-footed so that's a plus.

I'm sure Paolo knows what he's doing. If he's willing to spend 15m for the CB, then he already has in mind who'll be signing in midfield, which could potentially be a loan with option/obligation. We'll see.

Seems like he wants to leave on a free... Wants a big windfall from his move.

Don't know, but we're approaching crunch time of the transfer market and we have no concrete objectives (that we know of). We really need to hurry things up

Still hoping we'll make a final swoop for Ziyech for a loan + option. Chelsea don't want him, he doesn't want to be there. I think we're just waiting on them to cave.

QUOTE (CrazyMilanFan @ Aug 18 2022, 09:58 AM) *
i think latest on midfield is some Onyedika kid. His stats looks good and price seem to be in region which we might be able to get

We'll see, looks really raw from what I've seen. Was hoping for a more established player who could be an instant starter if needed

QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 18 2022, 01:24 PM) *
This is great news. Elliott won't hold any minority shares in the club as it was first hypothesised, so they'll hold zero interest and zero power in decision making.

RedBird will still owe them about 600m, so they might not still have a stake but they're still going to be involved as a financial partner according to what I read.

We'll see. So far I'm really skeptical considering we've just p!ssed away a mercato where so many good players were available and we had a budget that was smaller than Lazio's (!!)

QUOTE (Rossoneri7 @ Aug 19 2022, 03:29 AM) *
Milan seems set to keep Gabbia and with the return of Kjear, the defense is not a priority anymore.

A midfielder of a certain calibre would come in, with Bakayoko leaving the club.

Always said that midfield should be the priority, but still think we need another reliable CB. Gabbia simply isn't good enough
han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 16 2022, 09:08 PM) *
Basically, whenever you want to sell a company, the two most important things that potential acquirers will look at are the quality of earnings, and how much debt you hold.

We currently hold no financial debt, so that is very, very positive. The quality of earnings is measured by EBITDA (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation), also known as operating profit. It shows how much profit the company is generating solely based on its operations (and that is why elements like interest, tax etc. are not looked at). Operating profit is revenues minus operating expenses, which for a football club are primarily made up by football player wages. Hence, it's imperative to control salaries as much as possible, and consequently why we impose a salary cap and don't accomodate exaggerated demands like Donnarumma or Kessie's (Ibra is the sole exception).

Another matter that is investigated during a due diligence (the process of examining the financial statements of the acquiree) is to scrap from operating profit any extraordinary or non-recurring items of profit/expenditure. These could be the profit from the sale of any asset (such as a building, machinery etc.), or in the case of football clubs, the sale of football players. That is done in order to get a better understanding of an entity's predictable annual earnings. Hence, whether we had sold Donnarumma, Kessie etc. or not, for the primary objective of Elliott, which was to gain from the club's sale, it would have made zero difference. Sure, we would obtained hard cash in return, but perhaps the club felt that Donnarumma, Calhanoglu and Kessie's contribution to the cause (be it CL access or the Scudetto) was too important to let them go prematurely. And they probably also felt that they could have renewed their contracts given the circumstances.

There is definitely more to it, I am sure, but in a nutshell I think this pretty much explains our behaviour with relation to these renewals. This way, we've managed to keep salaries below our pre-imposed cap, and with increased revenues from new sponsorship deals etc. we've also improved our quality of earnings and become self-sustainable.

Now we'll have to see what RedBird will bring to the table. If they purchased the club to make it glorious again, then I expect a gradual increase in the salary cap and more contract renewals (along with some more spending during the calciomercato).

Thanks for the break down, still a head scratcher for me as to why they wouldn't try to sell earlier since money is the main drive...
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 19 2022, 03:06 PM) *
RedBird will still owe them about 600m, so they might not still have a stake but they're still going to be involved as a financial partner according to what I read.


Financial partner is simply a stakeholder. Same as when you take a loan from a bank. They have no say when it comes to decision-making.

QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 19 2022, 03:07 PM) *
Thanks for the break down, still a head scratcher for me as to why they wouldn't try to sell earlier since money is the main drive...


I think it's a mixture of factors and circumstances that made it very difficult overall.

These players didn't have a huge demand. Dollarumma barely managed to strike a deal with P$G as a free agent cos every other major European club who could afford him were already settled with their GKs.

Capanoglu also didn't have much appeal (otherwise he wouldn't have gone to Inter), and nobody gave two shits about Romagnoli.

The only player we could have properly gained from in my opinion was Kessie, but around this time one year ago the guy came out saying how he would return from the olympics and fix everything. Don't know what happened afterwards. I know for a fact that Maldini had very bad relations with his agent Atangana, who perhaps got into Kessie's head and convinced him to leave for free. Agents can be sneaky vipers like that.
han2503
We'll see, I really hpe they sort out Leao's and Bennacer's contracts ASAP

Kalulu, Tonali, etc aren't that pressing atm, although we should take care of both during this season as well, especially Kalulu.
CrazyMilanFan
Random news but westham are signing paqueta from lyon for 60m.. They also signed scamacca for 40 m I think, crazy spending. But we get some money on paqueta deal
X-Offender
So, after Thiaw we are very close to this Vranckx kid from Wolfsburg. CM, Belgian, 19 years old but already with plenty of experience having debuted at 16. For his age he looks very promising from what I saw.

Deal should be closed on loan with right of purchase set at around 11-13m.
han2503
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Aug 29 2022, 12:36 PM) *
So, after Thiaw we are very close to this Vranckx kid from Wolfsburg. CM, Belgian, 19 years old but already with plenty of experience having debuted at 16. For his age he looks very promising from what I saw.

Deal should be closed on loan with right of purchase set at around 11-13m.

Let's see if we can get it over the line.

The fact that we're not going for a RW when we have 2 amateur level players at best on that side for me is still egregiously negligent!!
X-Offender
QUOTE (han2503 @ Aug 30 2022, 06:28 PM) *
The fact that we're not going for a RW when we have 2 amateur level players at best on that side for me is still egregiously negligent!!


+100000000000000000
han2503
What do you guys think of the Vranckx and Dest deals?

Personally I think considering the non-existent budget it's good that we ended the window with 3 high potential players for practically nothing. Dest and Vranckx particularly are without any risk since they're both loans with options to buy.

Not to mention Dest can play RW as well. If Salad can play there we should definitely give Dest playing time there, far better player overall in terms of talent and technique imo
CrazyMilanFan
MILAN
In: Adli (m, Bordeaux), Origi (s, Liverpool), De Ketelaere (m, Bruges), Thiaw (d, Schalke 04), Vranckx (c, Wolfsburg), Sergino Dest (d, Barcelona).
Back from loan: Pobega (m, Torino).
Out: Kessi? (m, Barcellona), Romagnoli (d, Lazio), Castillejo (m, Valencia), Maldini (m, Spezia).

I think it is a window of gambles. If they pay off then it mihgt turno out to be one of the smartest windows as we spent very minimal amounts on most players.

Lets hope as Han mentioned high potential these player full fill that. and if they do then we do have a very good team for the the future.
X-Offender
The fact we didn't address the RW is a huge minus for me. I can't believe we'll have to suffer for another season with this Saladmaker-Messiah bullshit.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2026 Invision Power Services, Inc.