QUOTE (Jack Sparrow @ Mar 7 2012, 01:12 PM)

Of course the tactics changed. For around the 10th time this season, he switched to tactics he should have used from the start. We hung in deep, we were more compact, we pressured key players and attacked weak links. We were C.E.R.E.B.R.A.L!! It's not rocket science...look at the earlier posts in the thread where han2503 (who has a miraculous patience to state what our tactics should be match-to-match) states what we should do. And look what we did tactically in the first half?
- MvB hanging around or going forward in and across the middle. When he should just have sat.
- Mesbah on his CL debut, a B+ level defender at his best, being alone against Walcott AND Sagna.
- Emmanuelson against Song?? I mean really??!
What we should have done:
- MvB sits. If he would have stayed in his fucking position he wouldn't have made that stupid error that got him carded so early.
- Mesbah should have add Emmanuelson ahead of him for added cover. If he wanted to play 3 forwards, then it should have been a 4-3-3 and not a 4-3-1-2. I can understand the reluctance to have a mid-4 since we don't play that way, but a wing forward tracking back is something Urby has done with pretty good success in his career.
- Ibra should have been the one pressuring Song. Not Robs or Urby (these two were basically switching around the hole position). Besides having the ability to speed up the game at will, he is a fucking monster. He would have eaten Song up for breakfast.
And in the second half, ecstasy of ecstasies we did exactly that. And not only were they shut out, we even got a few chances.
Note these errors. I shall concede the first goal as a freak incident. Poor marking happens.
The second and third goals were directly due to Mesbah being in over his head...and you don't need a half time talk to fix that. A gesture from the touchline is all that's needed to fix things.
I don't agree with everything but that's not important. let's say he changed the tactics. so what?!
A few months ago you all cried about how he takes until the 80th minute to change anything at all. now that he does it at HT to save a tie, you cry about how he should've done it before the game. do you have to always complain?
The important thing is we're getting the results and more importantly -this is my personal opinion- playing some of the best and most balanced football over the past 5 years along the way. under Carlo (those last few years) I always felt bad at how defensive, and under Leo how bad at defending we were.
QUOTE
Coming to your earlier post where you LOL'd at Allegri haters and quoted my post. If you had read my subsequent posts, I did give him credit for stemming the rot. But I criticised him for the above tactical (in my book) noob oversights.
At HT, convinced that we were gonna crash out, you hit out at him saying he made us the laughing stock of the whole Europe which sounded very bitter to me, not to mention immature. if you hadn't given him credit afterwards, what would you have done? lol
QUOTE
Secondly, I read at least 3 interviews where he went on about how we should avoid complacency. Yet if the team comes out and does exactly that, then what does it say about his influence on the players.
Not much when a 'freak incident' right in the 6th minute changes the course of the whole game. I've said it before, I don't think the players were being complacent or arrogant out there. the pressure of the stadium and their early goal just got them nervous, especially our less experienced players. they needed a break to come to their senses again.
QUOTE
Do you realise what the f@ck that means?? It means he is one player fallout(Ibra has had it with coaches)..and one retirement(Rino) away from having his sync with the players at risk.
No it doesn't mean that. you're just inventing stuff about his lack of man management skills because he didn't treat Pippo and Pirlo the way you wanted.
QUOTE
Contrast this with some of the best man-manager coaches in the world (for me the top two are Jose and Carlo). In Milan, Carlo had no less than 5 team captains!! Rino, Ambro, Pirlo, Zee and Nesta. Not including the demi-god that was Maldini.
Even in his second season at Milan? Who were his 5 captains at Chelsea? who are they now at PSG?
Jesus, do you have to overhype Carlo (and nitpick about Allegri) in every way imaginable? let the f@cking man be! he's at the beginning of his Milan career, it takes time to build relationships and mutual trust.
I find these supposed weaknesses that you find in him very lame, Jack.
QUOTE
I have said this, Filippo has said, han would jinx it so he doesn't say it- but once we go through a bad patch- this team is under HUGE risk of imploding. Too many new faces with chips on their shoulders ( I don't want to call them mercenaries) but not enough proven, respected spine in the team.
Define bad patch.
We have already gone through a couple of very bad moments, both last season and this season. nothing happened, we didn't implode, no one caused any sort of trouble, and we managed to pick ourselves up again. so, I don't buy it.
QUOTE
Thirdly, I give him credit but not too much credit. A team that has ambitions of being top 5 in Europe, goes into a second leg with a 4 goal lead against a team which has a decimated mid-field (uh-huh don't forget...our second half was also easier coz Arsenal simply ran out of options to introduce)...and then proceeded to almost throw it away.
Didn't the same happen twice with Carlo though?
Yet you consider him the best man manager in the world next to Jose and a genius tactician, despite the fact that he couldn't do anything to prevent La Coruna and Istanbul from happening.
Talk about having double standards...
And before you shove Carlo's achievements in my face, let me just say Max will probably have won more league titles in 2 seasons that Carlo did in 8. so don't go there
QUOTE
If as a coach he couldn't do what he did during the second half, he doesn't deserve to be coaching Milan at all. We fired Leo for the same, and we can do that with Max. So sorry! If I go to a doctor for surgery I will thank him and say he did a good job but not praise him to the skies for doing what is in the end- HIS JOB.
Agreed. in that case he wouldn't deserve to be coaching Milan. but that didn't happen. so... you're making ado about nothing.