Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Champions League - Round of 16 - Arsenal F.C. - AC Milan
AC Milan - Milanfan.com > AC Milan > Matches
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7
d'Arc.LP
ABBIATI: "I saw the 4-0 vs Deportivo, the ghost was still there, but we have players with great personalities"
acid911
I know, it was a very risky option. Not that it matters now, but like I said, I'd have chanced my luck. smile.gif Say what they will, but we play much better with Aquilani. His is the creative spark we lack all too often. Not to mention his experience and cool and collected game. It was evident from the moment he came on.

And had we stifled the game for the first 30 minutes, first half, without giving a goal, then tie in the bag!
Jack Bauer
Of course we looked better with Aqui and it's well known that Allegri doesn't like to play 3 forward system unless he has no choice. Surely in important CL game. Aqui wasn't ready to start, as simple as that.
d'Arc.LP
X-Off will get this tongue.gif :

kurtsimonw
QUOTE (d'Arc.LP @ Mar 6 2012, 10:36 PM) *
ABBIATI: "I saw the 4-0 vs Deportivo, the ghost was still there, but we have players with great personalities"

And a coach that can get things sorted when a lead is slipping and the going gets tough.
Jack Bauer
QUOTE (d'Arc.LP @ Mar 7 2012, 01:45 AM) *
X-Off will get this tongue.gif :


That's how I looked after his miss.
Zed.D
QUOTE (d'Arc.LP @ Mar 7 2012, 03:15 AM) *
X-Off will get this tongue.gif :


Like the rest of us don't know what the Albanian flag looks like smile.gif
han2503
QUOTE (acid911 @ Mar 6 2012, 11:37 PM) *
I know, it was a very risky option. Not that it matters now, but like I said, I'd have chanced my luck. smile.gif Say what they will, but we play much better with Aquilani. His is the creative spark we lack all too often. Not to mention his experience and cool and collected game. It was evident from the moment he came on.

And had we stifled the game for the first 30 minutes, first half, without giving a goal, then tie in the bag!

It's still in the bag wink.gif

I think we shouldn't read too much into it. A lot factored into it. You couldn't have expected Allegri to start Aqui, simply because he was not ready to start. Arsenal played with a lot of intensity in the first half, they simply pressed us a lot hence some of the mistakes that the players were making. It was easier when Aqui came on because Arsenal just could not keep up that kind of pressure and they dropped off a lot around the 60th minute mark.

Yes Aqui is very important for our overall game, but starting him imo would have been a bigger mistake as he could have easily made a mistake under pressure given his lack of match fitness or gotten injured again.
Zed.D
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Mar 7 2012, 03:15 AM) *
And a coach that can get things sorted when a lead is slipping and the going gets tough.

Fillipo Simone
Abbiati for that save alone deserves MoM title. And we talk about Allegri deserving praise for turning the team?
Zed.D
QUOTE (Fillipo Simone @ Mar 7 2012, 02:23 AM) *
Abbiati for that save alone deserves MoM title. And we talk about Allegri deserving praise for turning the team?

Not taking anything away from the amazing Abbiati (he's proving it game after game) but that was more RvP screwing it up. just like Nocerino did.
amancik
QUOTE (Zed.D @ Mar 7 2012, 06:55 AM) *
Not taking anything away from the amazing Abbiati (he's proving it game after game) but that was more RvP screwing it up. just like Nocerino did.


+1
acid911
QUOTE (han2503 @ Mar 7 2012, 03:48 AM) *
It's still in the bag

Hence why I said not that it matters now. tongue.gif laugh.gif And Abbiati, well he made two live-saving saves today!
d'Arc.LP
Aquilani defends El Shaarawy: "The kid is only 19 years old, he still needs to miss plenty of goals."

Galliani: "I ran to the locker room right after RvP's miss. I just paced back and forth in the locker room so I didn't see Nocerino's error"
X-Offender
Whilst at it, welcome back Aquaman! We missed you. king.gif
Fillipo Simone
QUOTE (Zed.D @ Mar 6 2012, 11:55 PM) *
Not taking anything away from the amazing Abbiati (he's proving it game after game) but that was more RvP screwing it up. just like Nocerino did.

Really? Not in a million years. Difference is, Abbiati made a superb save after neutralizing the deflected shot at first, then managed, from the grass practically, to save Persie's shot.

While Noce just passed the ball into the keepers direction.
X-Offender
QUOTE (Fillipo Simone @ Mar 7 2012, 01:03 AM) *
Really? Not in a million years. Difference is, Abbiati made a superb save after neutralizing the deflected shot at first, then managed, from the grass practically, to save Persie's shot.

While Noce just passed the ball into the keepers direction.


+1
drucurl
Allegri:
  1. makes awful preparations/tactics and poorly anticipates Arsenal
  2. Milan get a First Half MAULING (Interesting that NOTHING happens is ever his fault but always the players)
  3. Halftime: he yells at the team not to throw away a FOUR GOAL LEAD
  4. No goals scored in the second half as Arsenal have worn themselves dry trying
  5. Allegri praised for being the uninsightful myopic small minded coach that he shows himself to be time and time again

huh.gif
William405
QUOTE (drucurl @ Mar 7 2012, 06:34 AM) *
Allegri:
  1. makes awful preparations/tactics and poorly anticipates Arsenal
  2. Milan get a First Half MAULING (Interesting that NOTHING happens is ever his fault but always the players)
  3. Halftime: he yells at the team not to throw away a FOUR GOAL LEAD
  4. No goals scored in the second half as Arsenal have worn themselves dry trying
  5. Allegri praised for being the uninsightful myopic small minded coach that he shows himself to be time and time again

huh.gif


What would have you done smartass?
kurtsimonw
Allegri didn't change tactics at halftime and we were much better. That shows the tactics were fine, it was the attitude of the players that was the problem and that's hard to adjust during a game. He changes it when he could. Job done.
Zed.D
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Mar 7 2012, 10:45 AM) *
Allegri didn't change tactics at halftime and we were much better. That shows the tactics were fine, it was the attitude of the players that was the problem and that's hard to adjust during a game. He changes it when he could. Job done.

Exactly. if it was poor preparation and poor anticipation and poor tactics, it wouldn't have worked in the second half.

We just succumbed to the atmosphere of the Emirates and the pressure resulting from an early, rather lucky goal.

QUOTE (Fillipo Simone @ Mar 7 2012, 04:33 AM) *
Really? Not in a million years. Difference is, Abbiati made a superb save after neutralizing the deflected shot at first, then managed, from the grass practically, to save Persie's shot.

While Noce just passed the ball into the keepers direction.

That doesn't change that fact that RvP tried to chip the ball and as a result it ended up in Abbiati's stretched arms - had RVP taken his shot low and with more force Abs would've had no chance.

All in all a great double save but I've seen more amazing saves from him before. very underrated GK.
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (Zed.D @ Mar 7 2012, 07:20 AM) *
Exactly. if it was poor preparation and poor anticipation and poor tactics, it wouldn't have worked in the second half.

We just succumbed to the atmosphere of the Emirates and the pressure resulting from an early, rather lucky goal.

I like it when we agree. biggrin.gif

QUOTE (Zed.D @ Mar 7 2012, 07:20 AM) *
All in all a great double save but I've seen more amazing saves from him before. very underrated GK.

Yep. The last few weeks alone he's made huge saves. First leg vs Arsenal at 3-0 up he makes a great save fromm RvP, that goes in and it's 3-1 and it changes the entire tie a lot. Juve at 1-0 he makes a point blank save from Quagliarella (I think?), if they make it 1-1 then, who knows they may have gone on to win. Then yesterday the save at 3-0 was again huge.
Jack Sparrow
QUOTE (Zed.D @ Mar 7 2012, 01:50 PM) *
Exactly. if it was poor preparation and poor anticipation and poor tactics, it wouldn't have worked in the second half.

We just succumbed to the atmosphere of the Emirates and the pressure resulting from an early, rather lucky goal.


That doesn't change that fact that RvP tried to chip the ball and as a result it ended up in Abbiati's stretched arms - had RVP taken his shot low and with more force Abs would've had no chance.

All in all a great double save but I've seen more amazing saves from him before. very underrated GK.


Of course the tactics changed. For around the 10th time this season, he switched to tactics he should have used from the start. We hung in deep, we were more compact, we pressured key players and attacked weak links. We were C.E.R.E.B.R.A.L!! It's not rocket science...look at the earlier posts in the thread where han2503 (who has a miraculous patience to state what our tactics should be match-to-match) states what we should do. And look what we did tactically in the first half?

- MvB hanging around or going forward in and across the middle. When he should just have sat.
- Mesbah on his CL debut, a B+ level defender at his best, being alone against Walcott AND Sagna.
- Emmanuelson against Song?? I mean really??!

What we should have done:

- MvB sits. If he would have stayed in his fucking position he wouldn't have made that stupid error that got him carded so early.

- Mesbah should have add Emmanuelson ahead of him for added cover. If he wanted to play 3 forwards, then it should have been a 4-3-3 and not a 4-3-1-2. I can understand the reluctance to have a mid-4 since we don't play that way, but a wing forward tracking back is something Urby has done with pretty good success in his career.

- Ibra should have been the one pressuring Song. Not Robs or Urby (these two were basically switching around the hole position). Besides having the ability to speed up the game at will, he is a fucking monster. He would have eaten Song up for breakfast.

And in the second half, ecstasy of ecstasies we did exactly that. And not only were they shut out, we even got a few chances.

Note these errors. I shall concede the first goal as a freak incident. Poor marking happens.

The second and third goals were directly due to Mesbah being in over his head...and you don't need a half time talk to fix that. A gesture from the touchline is all that's needed to fix things.

---------

Coming to your earlier post where you LOL'd at Allegri haters and quoted my post. If you had read my subsequent posts, I did give him credit for stemming the rot. But I criticised him for the above tactical (in my book) noob oversights.

Secondly, I read at least 3 interviews where he went on about how we should avoid complacency. Yet if the team comes out and does exactly that, then what does it say about his influence on the players. To me it is obvious by now, that Max is a pure albeit very very skilled tactician. Plain and simple. His grip on player management is very very rudimentary. Read that interview posted in the Allegri thread- "...two captains. Technical and tactical is Ibra and Character is Rino"

Do you realise what the f@ck that means?? It means he is one player fallout(Ibra has had it with coaches)..and one retirement(Rino) away from having his sync with the players at risk.

Contrast this with some of the best man-manager coaches in the world (for me the top two are Jose and Carlo). In Milan, Carlo had no less than 5 team captains!! Rino, Ambro, Pirlo, Zee and Nesta. Not including the demi-god that was Maldini.

I have said this, Filippo has said, han would jinx it so he doesn't say it- but once we go through a bad patch- this team is under HUGE risk of imploding. Too many new faces with chips on their shoulders ( I don't want to call them mercenaries) but not enough proven, respected spine in the team.

Thirdly, I give him credit but not too much credit. A team that has ambitions of being top 5 in Europe, goes into a second leg with a 4 goal lead against a team which has a decimated mid-field (uh-huh don't forget...our second half was also easier coz Arsenal simply ran out of options to introduce)...and then proceeded to almost throw it away. If as a coach he couldn't do what he did during the second half, he doesn't deserve to be coaching Milan at all. We fired Leo for the same, and we can do that with Max. So sorry! If I go to a doctor for surgery I will thank him and say he did a good job but not praise him to the skies for doing what is in the end- HIS JOB.

Bluesummers
For me we clearly underestimated them in the first half. We thought they would give up so we played at less than 50%.

After scoring 3 goals on us, it was evident that we had to fight for it and we went back to our normal level.


Only blame i'll put on Allegri is that the squad was too cocky before the game and we almost paid the price for it. Other than that, everything else was done correctly.
BrigateRossonere
I had several heart attacks this morning. panicsmiley2.gif
Jack Sparrow
Deep breaths and long walks my friend. It helps. I took one yesterday night. biggrin.gif
Rossoneri7
I fell asleep right before kickoff on my couch. Woke up at 3am when the replay was on at the 60th minute, we were down by 3 goals - Here I thought I was in the middle of a Wenger inception!

I stood up and walked towards the tv set ... Wondering if I should check the final result on the web, or continue to suffer. So I suffered till the final whistle and went back to sleep.


arivanjj
QUOTE (Rossoneri7 @ Mar 7 2012, 08:13 PM) *
I fell asleep right before kickoff on my couch. Woke up at 3am when the replay was on at the 60th minute, we were down by 3 goals - Here I thought I was in the middle of a Wenger inception!

I stood up and walked towards the tv set ... Wondering if I should check the final result on the web, or continue to suffer. So I suffered till the final whistle and went back to sleep.


hahahahaha i was wondering how you took the result considering ur pre match comment

QUOTE (Rossoneri7 @ Mar 4 2012, 04:28 PM) *
Not even considering watching this match ... We have four goals and they don't have an away goal. So, if we score an away goal on the night, they will have to come up with 6 goals, we score a second and they need 7 ... Unrealistic to be frank, especially when you consider the fact that we have already gone through a mistake such as Deportivo.

drucurl
QUOTE (William405 @ Mar 7 2012, 01:29 AM) *
What would have you done smartass?

I wonder if it's possible for you to unglue yourself to the n00b one's nuts to realize that almost everytime we try to play attacking football (i.e. tons of mindless pressing devoid of a system) AGAINST A DECENT opponent, we get SLAUGHTERED on the counter??

Rather hypocritical that "individual errors" are being blamed for all three goals dry.gif . I'm pretty sure Allegri gets credit for a watertight defense when we don't concede. Indeed everytime a goal is scored there is a high degree of blame to one or more members of the team. BUT When it happens frequently, it betrays a lack of competence of a SYSTEM. Under certain systems, defenders are more exposed, and under pressure and therefore more prone to make individual errors.

Take for instance the game vs Tottenham....everybody went on and on about Yepes mistake....indeed his decision-making could have been better, however under different conditions, with a better support system such could have been avoided.....Why am I bringing this up now? Because the same principle applies to the errors committed by Silva and Mesbah.....particularly Mesbah....he was getting SLAUGHTERED all game by Arsenal's wide play. Granted he did some hilariously moronic stuff but if Emmuelson, who spent the whole first half attacking, was there for backup, they would have been less glaring.

Thumbs up for Galliani's disapproval
Rossoneri7
QUOTE (arivanjj @ Mar 7 2012, 02:32 PM) *
hahahahaha i was wondering how you took the result considering ur pre match comment


I know, again I fell asleep even before the game started ... I didn't go to my wife's family gathering to watch the game, albeit I used that excuse to get away from the gathering biggrin.gif

I didn't expect us to go through a tough time, and thank God I didn't watch the first half otherwise I would have been trolling this thread adding at least 2 pages tongue.gif


In the end, the 4th goal at San Siro turned out to be crucial and not just a fancy show of football on our part cool.gif
Suhail 3
QUOTE (BrigateRossonere @ Mar 7 2012, 10:08 AM) *
I had several heart attacks this morning. panicsmiley2.gif

at half time mate, i think every milanista had his heart in his mouth
acid911
QUOTE (Suhail 3 @ Mar 7 2012, 05:42 PM) *
at half time mate, i think every milanista had his heart in his mouth

Apart from me. laugh.gif I was smiling all the way through. I had a belief even if we were down 4 goals, we'll win it in extra time. So much so that even if we were 0-5 in the 80th minute, we'll score another after a concentrated attack and a mistake or two from Arsenal right before the end of the match.

Having said that, had we gone out, I'd have been perfectly okay with it as well. Arsenal would have done to us what we did to them in the San Siro, only one better. wink.gif But all things considered, it was evident we played much better right from the start of the 2nd half. Much like how we play in Serie A against other teams. It was the occasion.
acid911
QUOTE (drucurl @ Mar 7 2012, 04:53 PM) *
Granted he did some hilariously moronic stuff but if Emmuelson, who spent the whole first half attacking, was there for backup, they would have been less glaring.

Can't disagree with this even if I tried. sleep.gif Urby was mostly in the wrong places at the wrongest of times. Besides, I am not sure he's got the physique to play as AM. And by physique I don't mean just the height. He gets tired easily the moment the situation requires him to burn rubber - that is against big sides, top quality opposition.

QUOTE (Rossoneri7 @ Mar 7 2012, 04:56 PM) *
I didn't go to my wife's family gathering to watch the game, albeit I used that excuse to get away from the gathering

Wicked. friends.gif That's the way!
X-Offender
Urby didn't play as AM. He played as LCM until Aquilani came in, but he attacked a lot, leaving Mesbah alone to deal with Walcott and Chamberlain. He didn't interpret his role well, looked out of place and didn't do much in attack either. Poor performance from him.
acid911
I meant to type AM, as in attacking midfielder. biggrin.gif But yeah, LCM is his definite position on the pitch, and like you said, I haven't been impressed with him in all the matches I've seen. In some he was serviceable, in others he scored and created chances against mid table teams. Aquilani, when he came on, was a much more creative threat.

I've been more impressed with the two guys in your signature (Boateng and Nocerino) as much as 10 times!
X-Offender
With Aquilani back last night and Boateng next weekend, we'll finally have our starting midfield back: MvB, Noce, Aqua, Boa. king.gif
acid911
True, and I'm just glad we got (or will get) Aquilani. cool.gif If you go back a year, I wanted both him and Montolivo, plus another quality attacking midfielder when we could spare some cash. He's the sort of guy who oozes creativity, at least when in context with the other teammates he plays with. So glad, he's back. And so glad, we brought him in.

I mean, take a look at the slicing through ball he gave to Nocerino (which he missed). That's what Kaka, Seedorf and others in their prime used to do week in, week out. Heck, even the one Robinho missed all those moons back, which made Aquilani pound the ground was brilliant. laugh.gif tongue.gif That's what I mean by creative players.

And frankly, Ibra, Nocerino, Boateng, Robinho, Pato cannot create scoring chances at will. And we shouldn't expect them to. Only Van Bommel can sometimes, Seedorf used to, and Pirlo did when he wanted to.
TriniKing_CE
I can't help but think of how much we're gonna miss Van Bommel in our next CL game.

Btw, how many yellows equate a suspension in CL?

I can't imagine if we were to go a CL game at this stage without MVB, Silva or Ibra.
X-Offender
QUOTE (acid911 @ Mar 7 2012, 04:07 PM) *
And frankly, Ibra, Nocerino, Boateng, Robinho, Pato cannot create scoring chances at will.


Ibra can do whatever he wants, whenever he wants to.
acid911
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Mar 7 2012, 10:42 PM) *
Ibra can do whatever he wants, whenever he wants to.

For others I mean. happy.gif The moment he has the ball, opposing defenders swarm him. Sometimes he can pull it off for the other forward, sometimes he is cramped for space. But a creative maestro like Pirlo, Seedorf, Kaka, Xavi, Inesta, and others regularly create opportunities.

I expect Ibra to score like Ronaldo, but if he doesn't create something from nothing like Ronaldinho, I don't blame him!
han2503
QUOTE (TriniKing_CE @ Mar 7 2012, 05:04 PM) *
I can't help but think of how much we're gonna miss Van Bommel in our next CL game.

Btw, how many yellows equate a suspension in CL?

I can't imagine if we were to go a CL game at this stage without MVB, Silva or Ibra.

Yep, he's going to be a huge miss for us.

But I think we should be ok for one leg if we don't face a Spanish side (or Bayern maybe).

All the other clubs in the competition are more than beatable for us if we play as we did in the first leg against Arsenal. And with Boateng and Aqui both back (hopefully no more set-backs for Boateng because his season is turning out as bad as Pato's injury wise)

So a full team back for the quarters should see us through even without VB in the first leg as long as we don't face a Spanish side (although with our luck we'll draw Real rolleyes.gif)
Fillipo Simone
That's a big "if". I'm not sure how Milan will do in the quarter finals.

One of the biggest problems with Milan is closing down opposition after a lead. We took up the lead against Barcelona, Napoli and Juventus, but were not able to hold back the opposition afterwards. That's an evident weakness teams like Bayern could exploit.
han2503
QUOTE (Fillipo Simone @ Mar 7 2012, 07:23 PM) *
That's a big "if". I'm not sure how Milan will do in the quarter finals.

One of the biggest problems with Milan is closing down opposition after a lead. We took up the lead against Barcelona, Napoli and Juventus, but were not able to hold back the opposition afterwards. That's an evident weakness teams like Bayern could exploit.

It depends.

Against Barca we were completely under pressure for 90 minutes, the Pato goal was as much a surprise to the team as it was for us. It's difficuilt when you're constantly defending in your own box to not conceed at some point. We needed to find a balance between the game we played at the Nou Camp and at the San Siro, as in one we were completely defensive and didn't even bother to play, while at the San Siro we went too all out attack.

Against Juve it was a completely different scenario. The team mostly got tired around the 60 minute mark because we did try to fight Juve at their own game, which is physicality and who can run the most. Something we're not too good at, not to mention the non-given goal which took the wind out of our sails during a period in the game when we were completely in control.

Against Napoli we were awful, our goal was just a small spark from a night when we didn't even show up. We were going through a bad period during that time in our season

I think it depends on the lead we have. 1-0 is bound to make you nervous as it is such a touch-and-go sort of situation to be in. While a 4-0 will tend to lull the team into a false state of security
Jack Bauer
We kept a lead many times under Allegri. Every team losses a lead every now and then, you can find enough examples.
drucurl
One thing's for sure this team needs Boaten nearly as much as we need iBra. Good call by Allegri for letting him make his contribution early
Bluesummers
QUOTE (X-Offender @ Mar 7 2012, 08:57 AM) *
With Aquilani back last night and Boateng next weekend, we'll finally have our starting midfield back: MvB, Noce, Aqua, Boa. king.gif

+1
Zed.D
QUOTE (Jack Sparrow @ Mar 7 2012, 01:12 PM) *
Of course the tactics changed. For around the 10th time this season, he switched to tactics he should have used from the start. We hung in deep, we were more compact, we pressured key players and attacked weak links. We were C.E.R.E.B.R.A.L!! It's not rocket science...look at the earlier posts in the thread where han2503 (who has a miraculous patience to state what our tactics should be match-to-match) states what we should do. And look what we did tactically in the first half?

- MvB hanging around or going forward in and across the middle. When he should just have sat.
- Mesbah on his CL debut, a B+ level defender at his best, being alone against Walcott AND Sagna.
- Emmanuelson against Song?? I mean really??!

What we should have done:

- MvB sits. If he would have stayed in his fucking position he wouldn't have made that stupid error that got him carded so early.

- Mesbah should have add Emmanuelson ahead of him for added cover. If he wanted to play 3 forwards, then it should have been a 4-3-3 and not a 4-3-1-2. I can understand the reluctance to have a mid-4 since we don't play that way, but a wing forward tracking back is something Urby has done with pretty good success in his career.

- Ibra should have been the one pressuring Song. Not Robs or Urby (these two were basically switching around the hole position). Besides having the ability to speed up the game at will, he is a fucking monster. He would have eaten Song up for breakfast.

And in the second half, ecstasy of ecstasies we did exactly that. And not only were they shut out, we even got a few chances.

Note these errors. I shall concede the first goal as a freak incident. Poor marking happens.

The second and third goals were directly due to Mesbah being in over his head...and you don't need a half time talk to fix that. A gesture from the touchline is all that's needed to fix things.


I don't agree with everything but that's not important. let's say he changed the tactics. so what?!

A few months ago you all cried about how he takes until the 80th minute to change anything at all. now that he does it at HT to save a tie, you cry about how he should've done it before the game. do you have to always complain?

The important thing is we're getting the results and more importantly -this is my personal opinion- playing some of the best and most balanced football over the past 5 years along the way. under Carlo (those last few years) I always felt bad at how defensive, and under Leo how bad at defending we were.

QUOTE
Coming to your earlier post where you LOL'd at Allegri haters and quoted my post. If you had read my subsequent posts, I did give him credit for stemming the rot. But I criticised him for the above tactical (in my book) noob oversights.

At HT, convinced that we were gonna crash out, you hit out at him saying he made us the laughing stock of the whole Europe which sounded very bitter to me, not to mention immature. if you hadn't given him credit afterwards, what would you have done? lol

QUOTE
Secondly, I read at least 3 interviews where he went on about how we should avoid complacency. Yet if the team comes out and does exactly that, then what does it say about his influence on the players.

Not much when a 'freak incident' right in the 6th minute changes the course of the whole game. I've said it before, I don't think the players were being complacent or arrogant out there. the pressure of the stadium and their early goal just got them nervous, especially our less experienced players. they needed a break to come to their senses again.

QUOTE
Do you realise what the f@ck that means?? It means he is one player fallout(Ibra has had it with coaches)..and one retirement(Rino) away from having his sync with the players at risk.

No it doesn't mean that. you're just inventing stuff about his lack of man management skills because he didn't treat Pippo and Pirlo the way you wanted.

QUOTE
Contrast this with some of the best man-manager coaches in the world (for me the top two are Jose and Carlo). In Milan, Carlo had no less than 5 team captains!! Rino, Ambro, Pirlo, Zee and Nesta. Not including the demi-god that was Maldini.

Even in his second season at Milan? Who were his 5 captains at Chelsea? who are they now at PSG?

Jesus, do you have to overhype Carlo (and nitpick about Allegri) in every way imaginable? let the f@cking man be! he's at the beginning of his Milan career, it takes time to build relationships and mutual trust.

I find these supposed weaknesses that you find in him very lame, Jack.

QUOTE
I have said this, Filippo has said, han would jinx it so he doesn't say it- but once we go through a bad patch- this team is under HUGE risk of imploding. Too many new faces with chips on their shoulders ( I don't want to call them mercenaries) but not enough proven, respected spine in the team.

Define bad patch.

We have already gone through a couple of very bad moments, both last season and this season. nothing happened, we didn't implode, no one caused any sort of trouble, and we managed to pick ourselves up again. so, I don't buy it.

QUOTE
Thirdly, I give him credit but not too much credit. A team that has ambitions of being top 5 in Europe, goes into a second leg with a 4 goal lead against a team which has a decimated mid-field (uh-huh don't forget...our second half was also easier coz Arsenal simply ran out of options to introduce)...and then proceeded to almost throw it away.

Didn't the same happen twice with Carlo though?

Yet you consider him the best man manager in the world next to Jose and a genius tactician, despite the fact that he couldn't do anything to prevent La Coruna and Istanbul from happening.

Talk about having double standards...

And before you shove Carlo's achievements in my face, let me just say Max will probably have won more league titles in 2 seasons that Carlo did in 8. so don't go there wink.gif

QUOTE
If as a coach he couldn't do what he did during the second half, he doesn't deserve to be coaching Milan at all. We fired Leo for the same, and we can do that with Max. So sorry! If I go to a doctor for surgery I will thank him and say he did a good job but not praise him to the skies for doing what is in the end- HIS JOB.

Agreed. in that case he wouldn't deserve to be coaching Milan. but that didn't happen. so... you're making ado about nothing.
Jack Sparrow
Finally. So a good discussion at last in Milanfan. Thanks zed.

You're right...parts of me were over-reacting. But you will agree calling us a laughing stock would have been perfect if we did lose. Even now, if you go online everything you read would make it seem like it was Arsenal and not us who went through. I had flashbacks of ManU under Leo...and I had a lot of beer. So..mea culpa!

But now if I were a team in Europe, I already have a confidence boost if I have to think of Milan. Barca just beat Leverkusen 7-0, I'm shitting my pants. Madrid are 10 points clear of Barca and have the Mourinho intimidation factor. Bayern have lost the title, which means for me the likes of Gomez, Ribery and Robben have it all to play for in the CL. And then there's Milan, who had stamped some sort of authority in the competition with the first leg, but the second leg tells them that we're just 'flat-track' bullies. If I were APOEL or Benfica OR any club, my strategy would be to just play for the draw in the Siro and then land the victory at home, coz Milan don't show up away.

In a twisted way, this might work to our advantage. Milan always perform better when we are underdogs, whereas when we are the 'favourites' in the fight we somehow f@ck it up.

Secondly, I didn't really mean to convert it into a Carlo vs Max argument. I'm a big Carlo fan (I even told that to Rafa Benitez's face)...but his time at Milan had come to an end. It happens to almost every coach unless like SAF the club can be re-made in your image. Italy does not let it's coaches do that. So no matter what I said, I don't want to see Carlo back at Milan, unless I dunno...as a director or something long after he hangs up his coaching boots.

And no, I don't really agree with your bringing up Max's titles too much. When Carlo came in, Serie A was still strong, there were better coaches, better players and far stronger teams. This is I think the first year since Calciopoli where we're seeing some genuine competition, and even you have to admit that Milan still has the strongest team by a country mile (if it weren't for our injuries). And two of your statementw:

QUOTE
under Carlo (those last few years) I always felt bad at how defensive...


QUOTE
And before you shove Carlo's achievements in my face, let me just say Max will probably have won more league titles in 2 seasons that Carlo did in 8. so don't go there


In his first season, in a new league, with a brand new team, he won the double and proceeded to set a scoring record of 103 goals which had not been done for 50 years. So I think here, I would reflect on the team and not so much the players. We had a semi-fit Kaka as our main attacker...so... unsure.gif

His second season was not as awesome, but then he was hit by injuries and hoisted with players he didn't really need, and yet from 15 points behind he brought it down to 3 before Roman Abramovich got scratchy-butt again.

Since taking over again at PSG he is undefeated. I think given all this, it's safe to say his reputation as a coach is not really up for questioning.

And that's it. I'm not bringing up the Carlo vs Max argument again. There are lot of things which I credit Max with doing:

- Remove the Pirlo dependency.
- Mitigate the Ibra dependency.
- Bring about a new playing formation
etc etc

So no, I don't want him removed. I just think there are some obvious mistakes here which is eventually going to be open to exploiting. And I want us to avoid it ASAP.

Barca taking the title of Greatest Team Ever from our 90s immortals has hurt me really badly. And I want that damn title back. So maybe it's just abnormally high expectations from my side.






kurtsimonw
QUOTE (Jack Sparrow @ Mar 8 2012, 09:56 AM) *
Barca taking the title of Greatest Team Ever from our 90s immortals has hurt me really badly.

In all seriousness, how do either of these compare to The late '50s/early '60s Madrid? If Barca the last 10 years and '90s Milan doubled their accomplishments in the respective era's, you might have an arguement.
Zed.D
@ Jack

I think just as you expect us to be the best in the league, you should expect Barca and Real to be the best in CL. for the same reason, we have the strongest squad in Italy and they have the strongest squads in Europe. I also think you're reading too much into what happened at Emirates. yes it was an unpleasant situation and should've been avoided, but that doesn't mean we're guaranteed to make the same mistakes in the next rounds again. we'll be cautious next time and should we go out it'll probably be because we don't have enough quality to remain in the competition. I didn't and still don't expect us to go all the way in the CL, we're just not there yet, but I expect us to progress further in the competition if we face any teams outside of Barca, Real and perhaps Bayern. we'll see.

As for Carlo, I said Milan in his last years we were defensive, slow and unwatchable. I didn't say anything about his reign at Chelsea. impressive records for a debut season, but you know very well yourself one season is not enough. on the other hand he still hasn't done anything special at PSG. with the vastly superior squad he has compared to other F1 teams, he should be unbeatable (same argument you use for Max).

In the end every manager has his own pros and cons. neither Carlo nor Max is flawless. the important thing is to win and we're winning so it'd be stupid to change anything. even if it's just a Scudetto, I'm alright with it, as long as we get that second star before Inter get their second or Juve get their third...
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2026 Invision Power Services, Inc.