Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: [EN] Premier League 10/11
AC Milan - Milanfan.com > General Football > Football Discussion
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42
Danny
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jun 8 2011, 03:32 PM) *
"These days"? Come on, we had 1 bad season where we lost our best player late in the transfer window and didn't have the chance to replace him. We had 4 different managers over the season and had the worst injury crisis in club history. Yet we still finished 9th, just a few points off Europe.

The previous 3 seasons we finished 6th. Finishing above Liverpool, billionnaire City and Spurs in the process. 3 teams that've qualified for the CL in recent years. Although I suppose the real question is, do you think Rangers are better than Villa?


Well it's hard to estimate a comparison, but it's worth noting that only one team in the world managed a clean sheet at Old Trafford last season. And it wasn't Villa.

Truth be told, the SPL, outwith the OF, is somewhere between League 1 and the Championship - Rangers and Celtic are a fair bit better than that.

Honest answer, I don't know. Last EPL team we played was Man City and it was a 2-2 draw.

What do you think? Villa better than Rangers?
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (Danny @ Jun 8 2011, 04:35 PM) *
Well it's hard to estimate a comparison, but it's worth noting that only one team in the world managed a clean sheet at Old Trafford last season. And it wasn't Villa.

That's one isolated thing though. We beat Arsenal at the Emirates, we beat Liverpool, we beat Man City. In 4 games against Chelsea and United we lost 1.

QUOTE (Danny @ Jun 8 2011, 04:35 PM) *
What do you think? Villa better than Rangers?

I would say yes. It may seem biased of me to say that, but the way players perform says it all for me. Steven Davis, Alan Thompson and Tommy Johnson were all sold by Villa for not being good enough but then did well in their SPL careers (okay, not so much Johnson but his scoring record was good up there). On the reverse, the very best the SPL has had to offer over the years like Petrov and Cuellar have been very in and out of what you call an average Villa side. I imagine players like Downing, Bent and Young would walk into any SPL side, but I'm not so sure your top players would walk into the Villa side. McGregor obviously would seeing as we have no keeper, but Bougherra, Weir, Davis, Lafferty and co. wouldn't. I think Jelavic would certainly make the squad, but I can't imagine he'd displace Darren Bent.

I'm certainly not saying it's a fact, by the way. We play in a completely different league and as far as I know have never even played each other competitively. The above is just my opinion. You're more than welcome to argue it.

And we've apparently offered Rafa Benitez a deal. I'd be very disappointed if so, especially after the disgraceful way he treated our club during the Barry saga.
Jack Sparrow
You got stuffed my Newcastle!!! MY NEWCASTLE!!! tongue.gif tongue.gif tongue.gif
Milan Are Brilliant
I thought Martinez was getting linked in the main Kurt? You will also love the fact Birmingham are signing Marlon King, a club without class, obviously.

Some crazy transfers yesterday, Jordan Henderson to Liverpool for £20m and Phil Jones to United for £17m.

Seems more likely Young will go to United, at least Fergie won't ruin him.

In other news Bolt thinks he's good enough to play for United, no one would catch him anyway. He'd be a rich man's G.Bale.
Danny
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jun 8 2011, 05:24 PM) *
That's one isolated thing though. We beat Arsenal at the Emirates, we beat Liverpool, we beat Man City. In 4 games against Chelsea and United we lost 1.


It's curious that you say all this which makes you sound like the bee's knees, yet you finished 9th. Or was it 10th.

QUOTE
I would say yes. It may seem biased of me to say that, but the way players perform says it all for me. Steven Davis, Alan Thompson and Tommy Johnson were all sold by Villa for not being good enough but then did well in their SPL careers (okay, not so much Johnson but his scoring record was good up there).


Davis' Villa career I know little about, other than he was voted YPOTY during his time there. It was Fulham we bought him from. Thompson cost Celtic about £5M - which back then was a lot of money, even in England. Tommy Johnson was tripe in Scotland.

QUOTE
On the reverse, the very best the SPL has had to offer over the years like Petrov and Cuellar have been very in and out of what you call an average Villa side.


Isn't this the same Petrov you made captain? And didn't Cuellar become a first team regular at RB until Houllier took over?

QUOTE
I imagine players like Downing, Bent and Young would walk into any SPL side, but I'm not so sure your top players would walk into the Villa side. McGregor obviously would seeing as we have no keeper, but Bougherra, Weir, Davis, Lafferty and co. wouldn't. I think Jelavic would certainly make the squad, but I can't imagine he'd displace Darren Bent.


Oh he would. Jelavic is outstanding - and he doesn't miss open goals. Bent's the most overpriced player ever. McGregor would, even if Friedel was still there. Bougherra's average, I don't rate him. Weir's at the end of his career but played for Everton for years so I think it's safe to say he's an EPL old boy. Davis on current form would. Lafferty maybe not.

QUOTE
I'm certainly not saying it's a fact, by the way. We play in a completely different league and as far as I know have never even played each other competitively. The above is just my opinion. You're more than welcome to argue it.


The one advantage is Rangers have held their own very well at the level of the CL - Villa have never even entered it. CL is of course even higher than the EPL.

This is not proof of anything, and as such I think we should arrange a competitive fixture between the two.

btw, did you know we're playing Blackpool and Chelsea this summer? Might give some idea...
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (Danny @ Jun 9 2011, 01:58 PM) *
Bent's the most overpriced player ever.

Kurt won't let you live that one down laugh.gif
il_diavolo_mtl
QUOTE
Premier League clubs post all-time high losses of £445m despite generating record income of £2 billion
*Pre-tax losses total £445m in 2009-10 *Premier League's total wage bill was £1.4bn, a record high of 68 per cent of revenue *All top seven clubs made losses except Arsenal


The Premier League's 20 clubs lost close to half a billion pounds last year despite income soaring past the £2 billion barrier for the first time, according to a report by football finance experts Deloitte.

The clubs in the top division in the 2009-10 financial year generated total revenues of £2.03bn in the face of the economic downturn. This was principally due to broadcasting revenue increasing by seven per cent to £1.04bn to become the first £1bn revenue stream of any domestic league in the world.

However, pre-tax losses deepened by 62 per cent to £445m as 16 of the 20 clubs were in the red, with only Arsenal and the three promoted clubs - Birmingham City, Wolves and Burnley - generating profits.

The Premier League continues to be at the forefront of the global obsession with football as it maintained its dominance as the richest league in Europe, followed by Germany (£1.4bn), Spain and Italy (£1.3bn each) and France.

The record revenues in England's top flight, which increased by two per cent year-on-year, were mostly used to pay ever-escalating players' wages and transfer fees. The Premier League's total wage bill in 2009-10 was £1.4bn, accounting for an all-time high of 68 per cent of the clubs' collective income, an increase of five per cent compared to the previous year.

The 20th Annual Review of Football Finance from Deloitte explains that cost control remains the key test for English clubs.

"The challenge for clubs continues to be converting impressive revenue growth into sustainable profits that allow for investment in both infrastructure and talent," noted Alex Byars, Senior Consultant in the firm's Sports Business Group. "The record pre-tax losses are a concern, particularly as credit is likely to remain less available to football clubs than it was two or three years ago.


Revenue-generator | Emirates Stadium helped Arsenal buck the loss-making trend in 2009-10

The continued reliance of clubs on owners such as Sheikh Mansour at Manchester City and Roman Abramovich at Chelsea once again highlights whether they can reform in time to meet Uefa's financial fair-play rules, which came into effect at the start of the summer window last week. Clubs will be permitted to record losses of only €45m (£40m) altogether over the three seasons from 2011-12 to 2013-14, and cannot rely on owners' subsidies, if Uefa is to sanction their participation in European competitions.

The figures in the report illustrate the lengths that the clubs must go to comply with financial fair play and come close to breaking even. The biggest loss was at Manchester City, where Sheikh Mansour bankrolled a £121m deficit to push for a Champions League place that they narrowly failed to achieve, while Chelsea posted the next most substantial deficit, £78m.

Double winners in 2009-10, Chelsea also spent the most on wages (£174m) with Manchester City (£133m) replacing Manchester United (£132m) as the next highest spender. Although there continued to be a strong correlation in the Premier League between finishing position and a club's ranking in terms of wages expenditure, there were exceptions.

Tottenham (£67m) came fourth despite having the seventh highest wage bill in the top flight, which was nearly half that of Liverpool (£121m), who ended up seventh in Rafael Benitez's final season in charge.

The Premier League remained the second most profitable league in the world, increasing slightly by £4m to £83m, but still some way short of the Bundesliga, which made operating profits of £113m.
Danny
QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Jun 9 2011, 02:33 PM) *
Kurt won't let you live that one down laugh.gif


I suppose I say that in the knowledge that 2 fairly average players yesterday sold for something approaching £20M each in the EPL. So Bent isn't alone on this.
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (Danny @ Jun 9 2011, 03:26 PM) *
I suppose I say that in the knowledge that 2 fairly average players yesterday sold for something approaching £20M each in the EPL. So Bent isn't alone on this.

Everyone here thinks they are both overpriced, I did, a few posts back I said about it. Bent is starting to prove himself though, when you look at Torres for £50m with one goal, Sheva wasn't as bad. But he's not English so I guess that is a blessing in disguise for him around the globe.
il_diavolo_mtl
QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Jun 9 2011, 11:23 AM) *
Everyone here thinks they are both overpriced, I did, a few posts back I said about it. Bent is starting to prove himself though, when you look at Torres for £50m with one goal, Sheva wasn't as bad. But he's not English so I guess that is a blessing in disguise for him around the globe.

that move alone has shifted liverpool ahead of chelsea.
CHU-LIP
QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Jun 9 2011, 05:23 PM) *
Everyone here thinks they are both overpriced, I did, a few posts back I said about it. Bent is starting to prove himself though, when you look at Torres for £50m with one goal, Sheva wasn't as bad. But he's not English so I guess that is a blessing in disguise for him around the globe.

What are you trying to say with the last sentence? Are you actually comparing Torres/Sheva (I don't know who you refer to with ''he'') who were one of the best forwards of their times with this Bent dude? Or what do you mean?
Milan Are Brilliant
I mean when you are English you are automatically overrated, overpriced & overhyped in the eyes of a majority around the world - even if you are good. So there are people on your back immediately.
il_diavolo_mtl
QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Jun 9 2011, 05:45 PM) *
I mean when you are English you are automatically overrated, overpriced & overhyped in the eyes of a majority around the world - even if you are good. So there are people on your back immediately.

it's not the players itself that are hyping themselves, but the loony media and commentators. I cannot believe how much the announcers got away with, especially in Real Madrid vs Tottenham, it was laughable.
kurtsimonw
EDIT: Whatever. Clearly Rangers are better than Villa. They are quite literally in a different league.
kurtsimonw
EDIT: Nevermind. "this Bent dude" is clealy not in the same league as Torres or anybody else foreign.
Danny
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jun 10 2011, 01:31 AM) *
EDIT: Whatever. Clearly Rangers are better than Villa. They are quite literally in a different league.


What the france was the point of replying to me if you were just going to come out with a reply like this? I thought we had a fair debate going and now you're chucking your rattle out the pram.
Danny
QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Jun 9 2011, 10:45 PM) *
I mean when you are English you are automatically overrated, overpriced & overhyped in the eyes of a majority around the world - even if you are good. So there are people on your back immediately.


There are plenty of world class English players like Lampard, Rooney, Ferdinand. But for some reason the 'decent' as opposed to outstanding players cost almost as much as the latter do.

Rooney cost Utd £25M or so - because he was a sensational talent. Now ordinary players are costing similar amounts.

It really does seem to be an English thing - is it due to the sheer amount of money in the English game?

Is this inflation?
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (Danny @ Jun 10 2011, 12:50 PM) *
What the france was the point of replying to me if you were just going to come out with a reply like this? I thought we had a fair debate going and now you're chucking your rattle out the pram.

I did have a reply, but changed it. I'm more than happy to debate with people if they're going to be sensible but comments like "Bent is the most overpriced player ever" and "are you actually compariing Torres with this Bent dude".. I'm not debating with that, at least show a little respect, both of you.

Bent over his career scores at a better rate than Torres (Bent ever 2.30 games, Torres ever 2.36). He's also had the misfortune of not getting to play for many high profiled clubs while Torres has played for 3 CL regulars. Then you're saying a guy who has had a few good years in Austria and Scotland is better than the man? Come on. Fair enough if you don't think he's one of the very best, but to basically laugh at people for trying to compare him to other top strikers is a bit over the top. £18m for Bent is not even close to being overpriced. His scoring record considering the teams he's played for us outstanding. He's the most prolific scorer in English football over the past 5 years, a list that includes the likes of Rooney, Ronaldo, Drogba, Berbatov, etc. I fail to see how he is overpriced with the transfers of Jones, Henderson, Suarez, Torres and Carroll. The media laughing at us looks rather silly now.

Talking of the media laughing at us. Ashley Young looks like he may be moving to Manchester United for £20m, despite only having a year left on his contract. And when we signed him supposedly we'd made one of the worst mistakes ever signing him for over £9m? 4 and a half years, 37 goals and 57 assists later, we've got great service from him and made over 100% profit. Never forget this goal, I was one of the lucky ones to be there.

LaPalma
QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Jun 9 2011, 11:45 PM) *
I mean when you are English you are automatically overrated, overpriced & overhyped in the eyes of a majority around the world - even if you are good. So there are people on your back immediately.

You English people seem to like your role as "the guys everyone hates" pretty much, he? People all over the world highly rate English players like Lampard, Gerrard or Rooney. But of course Brazilian and Spanish players always seem a bit more fancy. Because Brazil is Copa Cabana, Samba football, Péle and all in all...more fascinating in a sunshiny way. Players from "northern" Europe (except the Netherlands of course) like England, Scotland, Germany or Belgium will always seem less admirable than their Latin counterparts. It's their fate.
Danny
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jun 10 2011, 01:09 PM) *
I did have a reply, but changed it. I'm more than happy to debate with people if they're going to be sensible but comments like "Bent is the most overpriced player ever" and "are you actually compariing Torres with this Bent dude".. I'm not debating with that, at least show a little respect, both of you.

Bent over his career scores at a better rate than Torres (Bent ever 2.30 games, Torres ever 2.36). He's also had the misfortune of not getting to play for many high profiled clubs while Torres has played for 3 CL regulars. Then you're saying a guy who has had a few good years in Austria and Scotland is better than the man? Come on. Fair enough if you don't think he's one of the very best, but to basically laugh at people for trying to compare him to other top strikers is a bit over the top. £18m for Bent is not even close to being overpriced. His scoring record considering the teams he's played for us outstanding. He's the most prolific scorer in English football over the past 5 years, a list that includes the likes of Rooney, Ronaldo, Drogba, Berbatov, etc. I fail to see how he is overpriced with the transfers of Jones, Henderson, Suarez, Torres and Carroll. The media laughing at us looks rather silly now.


Quite a rant there. I suspect if Bent played his football elsewhere you'd be on our side.

Your view is completely clouded by 100% bias, which is fair enough. But you're also trying to use stats to show you're being completely honest and impartial. Which is not the case. I'm the same - I wouldn't be whoring Jelavic and other Rangers players in the way I do if they didn't play for Rangers.

But I suppose football is about defending your side passionately, and your players. So I have no issue with that.
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (Danny @ Jun 10 2011, 01:54 PM) *
Quite a rant there. I suspect if Bent played his football elsewhere you'd be on our side.

Your view is completely clouded by 100% bias, which is fair enough. But you're also trying to use stats to show you're being completely honest and impartial. Which is not the case. I'm the same - I wouldn't be whoring Jelavic and other Rangers players in the way I do if they didn't play for Rangers.

But I suppose football is about defending your side passionately, and your players. So I have no issue with that.

This is simply not true. The stats comparing him to Torres were there because of something Chu-Lip said. As for me being biased? I have always been a big fan of Darren Bent, here's posts taken from this very forum.

From EPL 06/07 thread:
QUOTE
Darren Bent IS top class. If I were Martin O'Neill I'd be on the Charlton right now with a £20m offer.

He's the best English striker by quiet some way. The service he gets at Charlton is awful, and he still out-scores Wayne Rooney/Peter Crouch on a regular basis. And he doesn't have Gerrard, Alonso, Kewell, Giggs, Scholes and Ronaldo giving him the ball.


From EPL 07/08 thread:
QUOTE
Great deal for Bent, he'll show that he's worth every penny of that. The best striker/scorer England have in my opinion, better than Defoe/Rooney/Crouch/Owen


From World Cup 2010 thread:
QUOTE
*Bent missing out is just not right, he's far better than all but Rooney.


So as you can see, while Bent was still at Charlton I thought he could be better than Rooney! He's still a better goalscorer, just not a better player. So no, if Bent played for another club, I wouldn't be on your side. Certainly no bias from me there, in fact I hate Spurs and Sunderland.
Danny
And despite your feelings about him, his record for England is 3 goals in 10 caps?

Best goalscorer? Clearly the national game doesn't love him like you do.

Anyway, you're obviously the biggest Darren Bent fan this side of the equater - more power to you.

I really can't be arsed talking about Darren bloody Bent anymore!
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (Danny @ Jun 10 2011, 04:17 PM) *
And despite your feelings about him, his record for England is 3 goals in 10 caps?

Best goalscorer? Clearly the national game doesn't love him like you do.

Anyway, you're obviously the biggest Darren Bent fan this side of the equater - more power to you.

I really can't be arsed talking about Darren bloody Bent anymore!

His goalscoring ratio is similar at International level to that of Torres and Messi, what's your point? It's also fair to point out that only 6 of those were starts, the others were mainly late subsitute appearances where he's hardly going to make an impact.

And I think it's pretty common for players at poor sides to not get into the International side. Look at Gareth Barry, James Milner. Barry played for a poor Villa side and didn't break into the England team until we were regular top 6 - despite him actually playing better before that. Milner didn't get a look in at Newcastle, wasn't until he moved to Villa he made the team. Players like SWP who couldn't even get in the Chelsea team play, then when they move away and play more regular football they get dropped. It's the way of International football, now at Villa Bent plays regularly for England and scores regularly.

But whatever, it's not rare for a Scot to hate on English player and their worth for no apparent reason.
Danny
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jun 10 2011, 05:39 PM) *
But whatever, it's not rare for a Scot to hate on English player and their worth for no apparent reason.


Yeah, because my praise of many English players is clearly rendered irrelevant as soon as I dare criticise your idol.

You're being totally unreasonable and making this an issue of xenophobia.

I'm done here.
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (Danny @ Jun 11 2011, 01:47 PM) *
Yeah, because my praise of many English players is clearly rendered irrelevant as soon as I dare criticise your idol.

You're being totally unreasonable and making this an issue of xenophobia.

I'm done here.

I'm sorry but this is hilarious.

Andy Murray outright says anti-English stuff and as a result, me and Ash dislike the man. You say our posts are bordering on xenophobic. You criticise Bent for no reason and when I mention it's because you're Scottish you say I'm being unreasonable and making it about xenophobia? Come on man, don't be a hypocrite. You're way smarter than this.

I meant to pick up on something you said earlier anyways. You felt Jelavic would get into the Villa side over Bent. Bent is proven to be one of the best scorers in the EPL (the best in recent years) and Jelavic has yet to even play in a top league. You apparently dismiss this and criticise Bent's 3 in 10 for England. Yet seem to ignore the fact that Jelavic has actually scored less goals in more games for his country. Just seems a strange arguement to me.

It's also getting very boring on here that everytime I defend someone they become my 'idol'. rolleyes.gif
Bluesummers
Spain's Thiago Alcantara: We have never heard of any of the England Under-21 players


laugh.gif
kurtsimonw
Who's Thiago Alcantara?
Bluesummers
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jun 11 2011, 04:27 PM) *
Who's Thiago Alcantara?

HAVENT YOU HEARD!! OMG DO YOU LIVE UNDER A ROCK KURT?!


He's only the greatest upcoming actor out of barcelona! He's already heading for the world stage with such performances such as "diving with grace" and "ohh refff!!! he touched mee!!!!!"



Film director Guardiola has come out and said: "While I would like to use Thiago in our latest upcoming campaign, he is not quite ready. He will need to work hard this coming term if he wants to emulate the success of such brilliant actors like Dani Alves and Sergio Busquets."
acid911
laugh.gif laugh.gif laugh.gif Vintage Blue, right there!
kurtsimonw
Quality stuff, Blue.
Rossoneri7
QUOTE
Manchester United’s U.S. owners may sell shares in the English Premier League soccer team in Hong Kong, the Sunday Times said, citing unidentified sources close to the discussions.

The Florida-based Glazer family has held talks with several investment banks about a listing, which would value the club at 1.7 billion pounds ($2.8 billion), the newspaper reported.


Bloomberg.com
Milan Are Brilliant
laugh.gif laugh.gif Blue
kurtsimonw
McLeish walks from small heath, rumour is that he's going to Villa.

Not good enough for us, but it'd be funny if the best manager in their entire history walks out on them to join us.
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jun 12 2011, 05:54 PM) *
McLeish walks from small heath, rumour is that he's going to Villa.

Think you could do better to be honest, don't really rate him.

Get used to boring football if you do.
Fillipo Simone
Isn't Rijkaard on the list as well?
kurtsimonw
McLeish - 8/11
Hughes - 4/1
Moyes - 9/2
Lennon - 20/1
Rijkaard - 25/1

That's the favourites at the moment. I'd be surprised if it's somebody not in the top 3 there.

QUOTE
Get used to boring football if you do.

O'Neill played pretty awful football too so at least we can still be 'successful' with it. McLeish has never really managed a team with much talent though, so maybe with players like Downing/Albrighton/Petrov/Makoun who like to keep the ball on the floor he'll play differently.
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jun 12 2011, 06:16 PM) *
McLeish - 8/11
Hughes - 4/1
Moyes - 9/2
Lennon - 20/1
Rijkaard - 25/1

Is that Neil Lennon? laugh.gif laugh.gif

Ok, things could be worse. He'd probably walk around with a handgun aiming it at opposition fans after derbies and then claim no one in this country has a sense of humour.
kurtsimonw
Well here's what our fans think of the possible appointment..

Fillipo Simone
Whoa! Sorry to interrupt your little Villa-manager poll, but...Steve McClaren just signed for Nottingham Forest???

They play in the Championship, right? How did he manage to fall so low?
Not that I'm against it, Nottingham is a club with history, and had some rather sympathetic links with Italians in the past, but...surely he could have got a better job, no?
Danny
A former Rangers manager at Villa. My only hope is he allows Cuellar to leave.
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (Fillipo Simone @ Jun 13 2011, 11:05 AM) *
Whoa! Sorry to interrupt your little Villa-manager poll, but...Steve McClaren just signed for Nottingham Forest???

They play in the Championship, right? How did he manage to fall so low?

Mainly because after what he did with the NT his rating here in England is incredibly low, far lower than on the continent (at least in Holland). He did well at Middlesbrough but people just don't forgive him for the lack of qualification for Euro '08.
Fillipo Simone
QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Jun 13 2011, 03:21 PM) *
Mainly because after what he did with the NT his rating here in England is incredibly low, far lower than on the continent (at least in Holland). He did well at Middlesbrough but people just don't forgive him for the lack of qualification for Euro '08.

I know, but he sure could have got himself at least a job in the Premier League or abroad, in Holland. Ah, well, he'll do good with Nottingham and maybe bring them back. That's positive.
kurtsimonw
McLaren is a very good club manager and I'm pretty sure he was going to be Villa manager, but the majority of our fans were very against the idea and our directors happen to read our forums so they decided to cancel the interview.

If Forest don't make it to the EPL under a manager like McLaren, I'll be amazed.
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jun 13 2011, 07:12 PM) *
If Forest don't make it to the EPL under a manager like McLaren, I'll be amazed.

I'd be surprised, if he gets money and doesn't, he needs that to do well though. Just like at Boro.
LaPalma
Don't really rate McClaren. What he did at Wolfsburg was not even half decent. He had the second richest team in Germany and almost managed to make them a 2nd Bundesliga team. He's just not demanding enough with his players IMO.
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (LaPalma @ Jun 14 2011, 11:49 AM) *
Don't really rate McClaren. What he did at Wolfsburg was not even half decent. He had the second richest team in Germany and almost managed to make them a 2nd Bundesliga team. He's just not demanding enough with his players IMO.

I don't rate him either, people go on about his success at Middlesbrough but that was in the main down to Gibson putting money into the club. I mean our NT I'm not saying is spectacular, but we have to be qualifying for tournaments - no excuse really.

I think he even had money at Twente right (in proportion to the Dutch League?). Though he still managed to win it with them, that should be deemed as a success.
Kazdoodle
Hes a meh manager to me. yes he can win the dutch league with Twente but he does not strike me as a guy that can take a team like valencia marseille or Arsenal wise and make them champions of europe. So usually around a sorta not Horrific bad omg but not a Godlike wonder of a manager. But doesnt seem like a Nice person though.

And well i know there was the lack of qualifying for euro 08 but that is a good long way in the past now. Wonder how he will do at Nottingham forest. Senses tell me ill just see another mowbray like at middlesbrough but then again they can be silly lol.

If i did see him as the new manager of chelsea....... kazdoodle would be a little concerned indeed
Danny
QUOTE (Kazdoodle @ Jun 14 2011, 02:34 PM) *
Hes a meh manager to me. yes he can win the dutch league with Twente but he does not strike me as a guy that can take a team like valencia marseille or Arsenal wise and make them champions of europe. So usually around a sorta not Horrific bad omg but not a Godlike wonder of a manager. But doesnt seem like a Nice person though.

And well i know there was the lack of qualifying for euro 08 but that is a good long way in the past now. Wonder how he will do at Nottingham forest. Senses tell me ill just see another mowbray like at middlesbrough but then again they can be silly lol.

If i did see him as the new manager of chelsea....... kazdoodle would be a little concerned indeed


Hiddink is a sure fire certainty there?

He'd win the league and the CL imo. Best manager around imo.
kurtsimonw
QUOTE (Milan Are Brilliant @ Jun 14 2011, 12:35 PM) *
I think he even had money at Twente right (in proportion to the Dutch League?). Though he still managed to win it with them, that should be deemed as a success.

In McClaren's spell at Twente, they made £9m overall in transfers. He took over, had to sell their best player, and still won them their first Eredivisie. Winning the Cup plus sending Boro to the UEFA Cup Final is hardly a bad acheivement either.
Milan Are Brilliant
QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jun 14 2011, 06:32 PM) *
Winning the Cup plus sending Boro to the UEFA Cup Final is hardly a bad acheivement either.

But he spent loads of money for a club of Boro's size, a bit like Redknapp has done previously really!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2026 Invision Power Services, Inc.