[Fillipo Simone]

For what it's worth, I have nothing against Pirlo, Leo, Kaka' and Sheva for leaving. They're entitled to leave to whoever they want if the club do not want to keep them/are happy to sell them.

But why should we threat all these departures the same way, when clearly the conditions were different?

[dst]

Pirlo's, Kaka's, Sheva's and Leo's cases are all quite different in my view.

[kurtsimonw]

But why should we threat all these departures the same way, when clearly the conditions were different?

I'm not saying anyone should, that's just my opinion. If any of them left and said Milan are a shitty club, this is a step up, blah, blah then yes I probably wouldn't like them. But I don't feel any of them criticised the club in a way that'd make me dislike them.

[nuh]

i dunno about u lot but i have nothing against pirlo..sheva and kaka' but yes i do have something against leo and him joining PSJ that fast just shows that he only joined inter to get back at us....leo actually had an agenda which was to get back at us....when pirlo left us he left in the most humble way without dissing the board or the fans...he left us with the most respect possible..he didn't even have any other offers....and i honestly don't know why everyone are still upset about the whole sheva saga the guy wanted to leave and he left everyone leaves and one point and he didn't even go to a rival club...when kaka left it wasn't even his choice and again pirlo we both milan and pirlo couldn't agree about the length of his contract and he left in the possbile way....leo is much different from the 3..and if u guys tell me that inter was his only option then thats bull cuz i remember roma offering him a role and he rejected it...i think it will be a problem if we all start hating players that leave..i think its only natural if a player leaves a club at one point...

[Fillipo Simone]

I'm not saying anyone should, that's just my opinion. If any of them left and said Milan are a shitty club, this is a step up, blah, blah then yes I probably wouldn't like them. But I don't feel any of them criticised the club in a way that'd make me dislike them.

So you would treat a Darren Bent transfer to Birmingham the same way as a transfer to Blackburn?

[kurtsimonw]

So you would treat a Darren Bent transfer to Birmingham the same way as a transfer to Blackburn?

If he never said anything, sure.

Kevin Phillips moved from Villa to West Brom, he then joined Brmingham. When interviewed he practically apologised to Villa fans saying he doesn't mean to disrespect the fans, it just made sense for him to stay in the area. I don't dislike him for it and I see no reason to.

Craig Gardner, however, slagged off Villa when he moved, so yes, I hate him. Liam Ridgewell also did the same, singing Sh*t on the Villa and such. Kaka', Sheva et al never did such a thing.

[CHU-LIP]

he didn't even have any other offers....

You really think Pirlo couldn't go somewhere else and Juventus came to rescue him? LOL

Pirlo and Juventus were nice in touch with each other before Pirlo's departure with Milan was a sure thing. A player like Pirlo could have go to many, many, many, many places. Outside Italy yes, but also inside Italy. He didn't hestitate a sec to join Juventus.

[Fillipo Simone]

Pirlo and Juventus were nice in touch with each other before Pirlo's departure with Milan was a sure thing. A player like Pirlo could have go to many, many, many, many places. Outside Italy yes, but also inside Italy. He didn't hestitate a sec to join Juventus.

...And you know that...how...?

[nuh]

You really think Pirlo couldn't go somewhere else and Juventus came to rescue him? LOL

Pirlo and Juventus were nice in touch with each other before Pirlo's departure with Milan was a sure thing. A player like Pirlo could have go to many, many, many, many places. Outside Italy yes, but also inside Italy. He didn't hestitate a sec to join Juventus.

Well judging by the reports he didn't soo unless u know pirlo's agent u can't tell me otherwise
and besides no one outside Italy would and should buy pirlo...come on seriously pirlo wouldn't cut it at barca or madrid... neither would he cut it at any other EPL team he is not 26 anymore....obviously juve is his best option

This post has been edited by nuh: Jul 13 2011, 02:00 AM

[Fillipo Simone]

I don't think there is a point in discussing this any further. We know our positions very well, of which none has move even an inch from it's starting point a few months earlier.

[CHU-LIP]

obviously juve is his best option

Best option, yes. That's different from his only option. It's his best option if you completely ignore Milan and Juventus being domestic rivals. Point being: I don't like that to be ignored.

[han2503]

Best option, yes. That's different from his only option. It's his best option if you completely ignore Milan and Juventus being domestic rivals. Point being: I don't like that to be ignored.

What you wanted him to go to some mid-table club? When he's clearly still too good for that? Your bias when it comes to Pirlo is laughable

He didn't want to go abroad, so his top club options would obviously be Inter and Juve. He chose Juve. It wasn't about money or some twisted reason you're trying to sell to everyone to make Pirlo out to be the villain in the entire thing

[drucurl]

What you wanted him to go to some mid-table club? When he's clearly still too good for that? Your bias when it comes to Pirlo is laughable

He didn't want to go abroad, so his top club options would obviously be Inter and Juve. He chose Juve. It wasn't about money or some twisted reason you're trying to sell to everyone to make Pirlo out to be the villain in the entire thing

When will you get that it's not about Pirlo being a villain or not. It's the fact that he gets the free pass for joining our biggest domestic rival when the others, Kaka, $heva and Leo were slaughtered (at least on other forums). Personally I never hated anyone for leaving our team (except $heva for his boo ho I wants my kidz to learns englishes) but the way people are rationalizing away Pirlo's departure and the idiotic statements he has made ("Galliani fears Juve" derp) is a CLEAR indicator of unjust bias and double standards. Nobody is attacking Pirlo. I don't even know the real reason why ANY of them left. But his deluded fans are annoying

[William405]

and the idiotic statements he has made ("Galliani fears Juve" derp)

Source,please.

This post has been edited by William405: Jul 13 2011, 08:23 PM

[han2503]

When will you get that it's not about Pirlo being a villain or not. It's the fact that he gets the free pass for joining our biggest domestic rival when the others, Kaka, $heva and Leo were slaughtered (at least on other forums). Personally I never hated anyone for leaving our team (except $heva for his boo ho I wants my kidz to learns englishes) but the way people are rationalizing away Pirlo's departure and the idiotic statements he has made ("Galliani fears Juve" derp) is a CLEAR indicator of unjust bias and double standards. Nobody is attacking Pirlo. I don't even know the real reason why ANY of them left. But his deluded fans are annoying

Please show me the exact article he's said this in.

Pirlo didn't leave for money or a more famous team, like Kaka and Sheva did. Or to spite anyone like Leo did (even though I never said anything about him and always defended his decision) Pirlo made the best choice for himself and his family. Juve were his best choice since he wanted to stay in Italy. He wasn't going to move to a team like Fiorentina or Roma.

You and chu are making such a big deal about this and it's ridiculous. The man gave everything to this team, helped us win everything. And when he wanted something from the club they shunned him like yesterday's left overs