QUOTE (Rossoneri7 @ Aug 20 2011, 07:45 PM)

Bro, I agree, we need someone of 'quality' to feed Kaka, thats what Iv been saying all along. Aquilani and Montolivo even when paired are no Pirlo and Seedorf. We need Pirlo/Seedorf quality players.
If you want to ascert to Aquilani starting if he were signed, I hope he does that good to earn one. However, his recent past says otherwise.
Kaka's quality/experience is what we need, a quality midfielder for him to feed from and an aid to Seedorf in midfield, thats what I want for this team.
The club has maintained a rather shady position recently .. But that does not mean the issues you are raising isn't a matter of concern. I am sure the club are well aware of Pirlo's departure, as they are aware of Ambro, Ringo, MVB, & Seedorf's age and expiring contracts at season's end.
This further cements to notion of bringing in quality in midfield, a Fiorentina esque midfield never got them anything noteworthy.
As I've asked before but never been given a straight asnwer. Name me two players who are on that level, are affordable for us and available, personally I'm coming up with a huge blank.
Once again, I think you're terribly under-rating both players. Aquilani would be our best option because I don't see that Pirlo/Seedorf level player coming in any time soon. However, once Aquilani is out of the equation should an injury happen then what? Maybe Seedorf but he cannot play more then once a week, especially if these injury issues crop up during those months when games come in tick and fast. That is why I believe we need both. Had we brought in Cesc, we probably wouldn't have had any money left over for any signing, and we'd still be in the same position should he get injured. That's why
for now I'd accept 2 good players instead of one top class player.
I personally believe that Kaka would be a bonus, a really great bonus but imo we can do without him, Robinho, Cassano or Boateng, even Seedorf could all play in the AM position and as they've demonstrated last season, they could do it to great effects. While the situation in midfield cannot be as easily brushed off.
We have plent of players with quality and experiance, some wih toooo much experience (IMG:
style_emoticons/default/wink.gif) We need to make steps ahead. and the midfield imo is our only real achilles heal. Great attack, great defence, good players in the midfield will be enough
for now to do better then last season, maybe nt win the CL, but do better. And maybe that makes me someone without any ambition, but personally I beleive that had we bought Cesc we still wouldn't have won the CL anyway so...
And it wouldn't be a Fiorentina esque midfield because we brought in their player. We have a top class DM and a top class box-to-box man, but no craft. That is imo, the missing puzzle, and big name or not, if that missing piece is filled we'll do great things this season. That is what I believe.
I guess as you say we cannot know. A lot of what ifs go into it. We cannot know how a top class player would fit in, or whether a Monto/Aqui combo would do better. You can easily spend ridiculous money on a player and he'll turn out a big dud for you, as has been proven time and again in big money transfers. I think the only player that lived up to his transfer fee imo has been C.Ronaldo.
QUOTE (Fillipo Simone @ Aug 20 2011, 07:55 PM)

Even though I don't feel comfortable with Kaka coming back, I must say, I agree with R7 to the extent that I'd rather have Kaka+Montolivo/Aquilani then Aquilani and Montolivo but no Kaka.
Personally I think we'd need all 3 for a huge push this season
on all fronts. But Kaka is mostly the bonus from that package
imo. We don't have the creativity or the depth in creativity in our midfield. You campaigned a lot for Cassano in attack, simply because you saw that we needed the depth in attack, because now we might have a lot of striker, but an injury or 2 and we'd be in a problematic situation. Same goes o our midfield, we might have a gazilllion DMs, but Seedorf is the only creator, and maybe Aquilani if he comes, which I'm still not sure will happen seeing as a couple of days ago Monto was the sure thing according to the media, who imo at this point know nothing more then us.
Should the hypothetical Aquilani get injured, then everything falls on Seedorf, and it's already been agreed by the absolute majory that he cannot handle that kind of work load.
Also it has to be said, that both players can occupy the position behind the strikers, so should there be injuries in attack, one of them can always take over in that position.
My point being that if we do bring in Aquilani, then we'd need someone else for the midfield, Kaka or no Kaka.