QUOTE (Danny @ Mar 4 2013, 04:42 PM)
4-3-3's biggest problem is it requires VERY specific player types for it to work. Barca are truly the marquee model, until Europe started figuring them out.
In short it needs a DM (Busquets), a CM (Xavi) and an AM (Iniesta). It also requires a front 3 where the left and right prongs are more creators and wingers while the centre-forward is the main goal threat.
This is basic stuff.
It's a good formation to use at home against weaker opposition, and if you have the players for it it's good away too.
We used it going forward in the first leg, while reverting to a 4-5-1 when defending. That is usually the all-round best deployment of it.
Barca's issue is they can't do the 4-5-1 defending part. They get caught easily by the 4-3-3 on the counter.
Dare I say it we can do both.
The problem for us this season is that we do not have 95% of the requirements you've pointed out above
DM: DJ out pretty early in the season, Ambro cannot cope playing a certain amount of games
AM: No one really on this team is a proper AM
Winger/Creator for the 2 wide men up front: None (Maybe Bojan but they've never really given him enough time to try and make an impact. SES is far from being the type of player you described up there.
The only ones that really hit the criteria are Monto (CM) and Pazzo/Balo (CF)
So it's not that simple, and imo, it's the biggest reason as to why we struggled so much to put in even decent performances let alone start to win games. Now I think Allegri found the best formula for using the 4-3-3 with the players he has.
And for me, I see it as Barca's biggest problem being their extreme egotistic nature of playing as to why they're so susceptible to the counter attack. Playing such a high line with your FBs basically forming part of a 5 man attacking line with none of the mids dropping back to the level of the CBs just requires one good ball to set the opposition off on a 3 v 2 counter situation.
And now that they've hit a slump in form and they're not retaining the ball as well as they used to has made them even more vulnerable to this