So, let's see what comes out. I've had my doubts to include Abbiati as well because he never gets his fair share of praise, but it would have been too controversial.

Voted for Nesta. Some of his performances last season, even though he wan't always helathy, reminded how much we gonna miss his rare quality.

+1 same here with me

Close between Silva and Nesta. Went with Silva because I think Nesta missed too many games.

+1

+2

Silva could have crawled through a fox hole and saved private Ryan. I would still have voted for nesta.

We should have named this thread Nesta vs Thiago (2011 - 2012)

Mesbah might have had a chance though


Voted Nesta for this season.For various reasons such as handling the world's best player.

Righhhhht.

Voted for Nesta

Thiago Silva, shame he got injured. That was (another) bad luck that cost us.

Surprising to see Nesta winning this, but well, he's Nesta, so no complainments there.

And now both are gone... damn

It's very sad that Silva's last game with us was the Milan-Roma one (pre-Barça), where he got injured after only 5 minutes.

13

Thaigo Silva has been amazing last season but no doubt about it, it's Nesta. I forget that he's 36 years old sometimes. His preformance and quality shows a new side of italian football and will be absoulty missed!

Ah..there you are. Hey girl..whatcho been upto?