The rule is simple. A person comes out with a footballer's name, the next person has to rate the player according to a scale of 0-10. Let me give you an example; (and please keep it realistic)
Tabare Viudez - 6.4
and when I mention a name, the next person has to do what I did.
Robert Acquafresca?
Full Version: Rate These Players!
Robert Acquafresca- 7.6
Clarence Seedorf?
Clarence Seedorf?
Clarence Seedorf......8
Massimo Oddo?
Massimo Oddo?
Do we rate that player's top performances or his current form? Because if it's the latter Seedorf is nowhere above 5 and mishie gets a 3 for giving him an 8.
Oddo? 5.
Giovinco.
Oddo? 5.
Giovinco.
On current form please...
Giovinco - 7.9
Antonio Cassano?
Giovinco - 7.9
Antonio Cassano?
You are generous!
QUOTE (amancik @ Jul 12 2009, 04:58 AM) 
On current form please...
Giovinco - 7.9
Antonio Cassano?
Giovinco - 7.9
Antonio Cassano?
Antonio Cassano 7.1
didier drogba (hideous name btw. dont let that influence ur answer
)
QUOTE (Habitant @ Jul 11 2009, 10:11 PM)
Antonio Cassano 7.1
didier drogba (hideous name btw. dont let that influence ur answer)
didier drogba (hideous name btw. dont let that influence ur answer
)Drogba 8.8
Juan manuel Vargas
Juan manuel Vargas 6.5
Gonzalo Higuain
Gonzalo Higuain
Higuain 6 and (I think we should do this for young players) potential: 7
QUOTE (dst @ Jul 12 2009, 03:24 PM)
Higuain 6 and (I think we should do this for young players) potential: 7
(come on, he's better than that!)
You forgot to name someone.
More? Come on man, if top is 9 you really think he's more than a 6!??
QUOTE (dst @ Jul 12 2009, 04:26 PM)
More? Come on man, if top is 9 you really think he's more than a 6!??
top is 10
I think 6.5 or 7 would be more fair (at least his potential is that). but that's just me!Don't you want to name the next player?
next player: 0
Christoph Metzelder
Christoph Metzelder
Christoph Metzelder - 6.5
Next player: Emerson
Next player: Emerson
QUOTE (dst @ Jul 12 2009, 12:54 PM)
Higuain 6 and (I think we should do this for young players) potential: 7
Potential 7.. I know you don't like Madrid, but come on!
Emerson based on current performance would be a 4. Based on talent an 8.
emerson 2
Ibra
Ibra
Ibra 7
Dinho
Dinho
QUOTE (Coldest @ Jul 13 2009, 07:17 AM)
Ibra 7
Dinho
Dinho
Dinho - 6.5 - yes, he wasnt that good last season. But i know he will take it atleast upto 8 this season
Cigarini
QUOTE (Zed.D @ Jul 12 2009, 04:14 PM)
top is 10 I think 6.5 or 7 would be more fair (at least his potential is that). but that's just me!
I think 6.5 or 7 would be more fair (at least his potential is that). but that's just me!QUOTE (kurtsimonw @ Jul 12 2009, 05:16 PM)
Potential 7.. I know you don't like Madrid, but come on!
To be clear: I'm rating what these guys can do at their best and on a permanent basis. Everyone can be a 9 for a night or two. If Higuain is more than a 6 now then what was The Real Ronaldo at his best a 15!?!?
QUOTE (Protogonist @ Jul 12 2009, 04:50 PM)
next player: 0
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.