QUOTE (dst @ Nov 10 2008, 12:33 PM)
Excuse me but while I don't rate Carletto that high, I still think he's done very well in the league considering he only lost the league in '05 and '06 because Juventus were cheating with offside goals and retakes of penalties! Whoever has watched those two tournaments from start to finish can tell that gifted points were what gave them the Scudetto.
I think after these two losses he's gone crazy, I can find no other explanation why anyone would field Emerson let alone ask for him to be signed.
Agreed, zd, I understand your frustrations with Carlo because I share them, believe me I do. But all these defensive close minded tactics started exactly the season that Sheva left in. When Sheva was here before we ALWAYS played with 2 strikers 3 no 10s and a defensive mid. Even when we played the xmas tree in our Scudetto winning season it was always, Rui, Kaka, Seedorf, Pirlo and Rino behind Sheva. Never did he use both Ambro and Rino together. And back then the xmas tree was considered just as offensive as the usual 4-3-1-2.
It's only when Sheva left that he reverted to his old style of football that he used to deploy at Juve, the type of football that labeled him the 'Almost Man'
Carlo at Milan didn't even try to be defensive because if he would Silvio would lash out at him in the media demanding 'beautiful football'.
Like dst said, we deserved the 05 and 06 Scudettos based on merits and the quality of football we displayed, back then we rivaled Barca as one of the best attacking teams in Europe.
dst got it right, Carlo went crazy, simple as that. And after this season we should replace him either with Spalletti or Rijkaard or even Prandelli
QUOTE (Il Diavolo @ Nov 10 2008, 01:29 PM)
I disagree about Carlo being a loser. We deserved to win the league in 2005 and 2006. Ah, well, they gave it to Inter anyway, but in both seasons, Milan played with imagination, scored a lot of goals and only luck tooks the first place away from us. Remember how we scored 85 goald in 38 matches? Not bad for a "defensive coach" with "loser mentality". The past two seasons, it was all about Champios League and I can't really blame Carlo for his failiure to fight for the Scudetto. Our selection was horrible. No forwards, no defenders, degrading Dida, no alternative for Pirlo. It was hard.
Like I said above, Carlo didn't have the so called 'loser mantelity' a couple of seasons ago, we always went out with our most attacking lineup and with the aim to score goals. It's these past 2 seasons (3 including this one) that Carlo has reverted back to his old ways. He's close minded, afraid to stray away from his comfortable zone of first 11 and tactics and too afraid to make neccissary changes in matches, while waiting too long to make subs. And I'm not even going to get into the subs he makes (like for like, putting in Brocchi or Puma ahead of Yoann and so on
)