Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Serie A with playoffs?
AC Milan - Milanfan.com > AC Milan > News > Archive 06/07
Fillipo Simone
undefined American Style Playoffs For Serie A?undefined

The President of Lega Calcio, Antonio Matarrese stated that he would be in favour of introducing these new rules to generate new income and also add more interest to the season.


With Inter already almost certain of winning the league title, with more than half of the season still to be played, the Lega are trying to come up with ideas to make future leagues more interesting, especially for the title race.

The most accredited idea seems that of introducing the American style playoff and decreasing the number of Serie A teams to either 16 or 18, with two relegations instead of the current three.

The first eight would then face each other in direct clashes, starting from the quarter finals, and the final winner would take home the Scudetto. This would also be valid for the relegation issue with the last eight facing each other out.

To compare: In America's top-flight, MLS, presently the top eight teams at the end of the regular season qualify for the MLS Cup playoffs.

Goal.com

puke.gif
han2503
Portman
No, thanks.
misha
Really bad idea
Rossoneri7
Hell no !!!! mad.gif

WHo's crazy idea is this anyways, fire him ! king.gif
Warchant
apprently you guys have never seen a playoff system in action

there is, honestly, nothing more exciting

and it is the only way to trully name a #1
misha
QUOTE (Warchant @ Dec 16 2006, 07:09 AM)
apprently you guys have never seen a playoff system in action

there is, honestly, nothing more exciting

and it is the only way to trully name a #1
*

I am a huge NBA fan but I don't think the playoff system should be used here. It's more fair with the current system cuz that way the champion is the team that was better during almost the entire season, and not the team that is in better shape in closing stages of year.
Rossoneri7
QUOTE (mishale @ Dec 16 2006, 09:01 AM)
I am a huge NBA fan but I don't think the playoff system should be used here. It's more fair with the current system cuz that way the champion is the team that was better during almost the entire season, and not the team that is in better shape in closing stages of year.
*


Me too ...

I'm with misha on this one .. Plus we play CL .. So it would mean that we will be at a disadvantage when teams from EPL, etc etc play us.
X-Offender
Very bad idea.
vito_online
No, No, & NO realmad.gif
han2503
QUOTE (mishale @ Dec 16 2006, 06:01 AM)
I am a huge NBA fan but I don't think the playoff system should be used here. It's more fair with the current system cuz that way the champion is the team that was better during almost the entire season, and not the team that is in better shape in closing stages of year.
*


Was going to answer to Warchant but you took the words rtight out of my mind.

There is the CL to see who is better in head to heads. The league is to see who is the most consistant team over the course of a whole year.
Warchant
QUOTE (mishale @ Dec 16 2006, 01:01 AM)
I am a huge NBA fan but I don't think the playoff system should be used here. It's more fair with the current system cuz that way the champion is the team that was better during almost the entire season, and not the team that is in better shape in closing stages of year.
*


but what if there are 2 or 3 teams that are strong all year and the first place team wins by 1 or 2 points and only beats 3rd place by 3 or 4 points...how does this make them a "stronger" team than the ones they barely defeated?

note: i'm not saying this would even work in serie a...but from every sport i've ever watched...a playoff system is the only true way to name a #1, plus it gives more teams than just the most powerful ones a chance at the title.
redbabies
the WORST idea ever !!!!!
even the 8th team with a bit of luck can become a champion.
Imagine Ascoli to represent Italy in CH.L. as a champion - terrible.
han2503
QUOTE (Warchant @ Dec 16 2006, 05:23 PM)
but what if there are 2 or 3 teams that are strong all year and the first place team wins by 1 or 2 points and only beats 3rd place by 3 or 4 points...how does this make them a "stronger" team than the ones they barely defeated?

note: i'm not saying this would even work in serie a...but from every sport i've ever watched...a playoff system is the only true way to name a #1, plus it gives more teams than just the most powerful ones a  chance at the title.
*


But what if the team in first place is something like 13 points infront of the team in second, and then just has a bad night in a knock out game.

I wouldn't consider this fair for the team that has worked hard all season to accumalate all those points and then lose it all just because of one bad game
misha
QUOTE (han2503 @ Dec 16 2006, 11:01 PM)
But what if the team in first place is something like 13 points infront of the team in second, and then just has a bad night in a knock out game.

I wouldn't consider this fair for the team that has worked hard all season to accumalate all those points and then lose it all just because of one bad game
*

Agreed
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2026 Invision Power Services, Inc.