QUOTE (drucurl @ Oct 5 2011, 11:12 AM)
I prefer to deal with the FACTS:
1) Since joining Inter, EVERY team iBra has played for has failed spectacularly in most big games, esp in Europe. Every team he’s left since has done well with a more team integrated approach
2) He is a violent player. Whitewash it all you want but it’s part of the reason the referees sort of ignore him these days when he gets fouled…kind of how legitimate penalties aren’t given to Pippo because of his diver history
3) His mentality is one of an ambitious player no doubt but is not tempered with humility or compassion. Screaming incessantly for the ball and declaring BS things like “pass ME the ball more and we’ll win” (paraphrasing) does nothing for the team spirit or morale. Other nonsense like the “I prefer Pippo to the Brazilians” etc come to mind
4) The whole “iBra is our leader” thing is VASTLY overrated. ALL of our strikers scored 14 league goals and his CL exploits were mediocre. Not only this but he completely disappeared in the second half of the season. Our leaders were NESTA and Silva THEN iBra and Robinho/Pato.
5) Getting older. Is 30 now and fast becoming ANOTHER OLD SLOW, HIGHLY paid player
6) Nice to see his “I’m losing motivation” comments being rationalized away by the groupies (IMG:
style_emoticons/default/cool.gif) . If most anyone else said the same they would have been called “spoiled”, “mercenary” etc etc But as iBra is a forum darling of sorts he gets a free pass. Again, kicking Strasser in training, the fight with Onyewu and the continued animosity towards Pato have all been swept under the rug in exchange for his game winning performances before Christmas.
7) Allegri is at his laziest and worst with iBra on the field. We become a poor man’s version of the old Printer where the team forms a wall behind iBra, and with 0 creativity in hand, expect him to BE the offense (IMG:
style_emoticons/default/sleep.gif)
Even with all of the above ssid he IS a champion and does bring a lot of positives to the team. With Pato failing to be as consistent as we need he is our best striking option atm. Who needs to be ERADICATED is Allegri (IMG:
http://www.milanfan.com/forums/style_images/bullet/folder_post_icons/icon8.gif)
I disagree
1) i do think Inter and Barca's treble had littlw to do with the lack of Ibra... Granted Inter got better, but they had mourinho making the whole team attack and defend and also they got eto'o practically for peanuts, which helped.
2) I would say he defends himself, sometimes to a fault but i would not say he is violent like Cana or anything. I do honestly believe he is a tough guy and not violent by nature as you make him out to be. Hell, even pato was pushing and showing last game he played and i'd hardly consider him a goon... Hell i've seen rAmbro blatantly and viciously foul players and he is the team captain...
3) God forbid he should speak his mind.... Granted sometimes it does cause a controversy, again, to a fault but is he really that far off? Even our cocky Swagdorf knows deep down inside Ibra is 85% of our offense atm. I kind of like that sincerity about him, the same way i like Zeman's honesty. Football needs some off-color stars that don't necessarily think they are richer, better looking and smarter then everyone. I am 1 who honestly believes if we gave him the ball more we can win more...
4) Ibra was our leader because while we were playing like **** at the beginning of the season last year, he was getting all these wondergoals against the grain of play. Surely i wasn't the only one to think he saved our as$ess on more then one occasion...
5) i think grouping Ibra, arguably the best CF in the world, with the likes of Rino, Ambro and Seedorf is truly an example of a false equivalency (IMG:
style_emoticons/default/dry.gif) ... Surely you must to...
6) this speaks plenty of the squad, coaches then it does him being lazy. you can hate the comments all you want but you can't tell me with a straight face that Seedorf, ambro and rino have the same motivation. We have seen, especially in Serie A, old-timers prolong their careers with hard work and conditioning, i doubt the 3 aforementioned musketeers give a **** about keeping in shape to compete. He says it, and yes he probably means it, but i do think when he will retire, I for one will cherish the moments he had here and not think of it as a taint to a truly legendary career. Besides...winning heals all woes.
7) "
Allegri is at his laziest and worst with iBra on the field." your going to have to explain this to me, i was not aware ibra stupefied Allegri...